Miami vs Duke

#26
#26
Just saw the replay on ESPN 2

That was ridiculous!!

Duke just got trolled mad heavy.
 
#27
#27
bamawriter said:
Not true. The whole "game can't end on a defensive penalty" thing is a myth. The game can't end on ANY penalty. But there are very few situations where an offensive penalty would be accepted at the end of a game. Tonight was one of them.
Click to expand...
You're going to need to quote the rulebook to prove it to me. Because I know that is the case in the NFL and am pretty sure it is the case in NCAAF. And the reason for that is so you can't intentionally commit egregious penalties to score so that you can just get another play and do the same egregious stuff all over again and again and again.

I just looked at the replay and the officials did a great job on the last two blocks. In both cases the blocker was between the runner and the tackler, and to make the tackle the tackler would need to have faced the blocker. And in both cases the tacklers turned their backs to the blocker at the last second. The only question to me was whether #1 knee was down as he made the one handed lateral at the 25 yard line.
 
Last edited:
#30
#30
Duke got screwed big time!

Refs are a flat out Joke tonight.

They need to check to see if any of these refs have some gambling debts.
 
Last edited:
  • Like
Reactions: 3 people
#31
#31
ZZ13 said:
You're going to need to quote the rulebook to prove it to me. Because I know that is the case in the NFL and am pretty sure it is the case in NCAAF. And the reason for that is so you can't intentionally commit egregious penalties to score so that you can just get another play and do the same egregious stuff all over again and again and again.

I just looked at the replay and the officials did a great job on the last two blocks. In both cases the blocker was between the runner and the tackler, and to make the tackle the tackler would need to have faced the blocker. And in both cases the tacklers turned their backs to the blocker at the last second. The only question to me was whether #1 knee was down as he made the one handed lateral at the 25 yard line.
Click to expand...

The first block in the back was murder..... No way a competent official within five miles misses that one
 
  • Like
Reactions: 1 person
#34
#34
ZZ13 said:
You're going to need to quote the rulebook to prove it to me. Because I know that is the case in the NFL and am pretty sure it is the case in NCAAF.
Click to expand...

You're wrong about the NFL too. The rulebook for both says that if the clock hits zero at the end of a half, and an accepted penalty occurs on the play, there will be an untimed down.

But the only instance when a defense would accept a penalty rather than simply letting the game end would be if the offense scored on the play. Otherwise, there is absolutely no benefit to accepting.
 
#36
#36
bamawriter said:
You're wrong about the NFL too. The rulebook for both says that if the clock hits zero at the end of a half, and an accepted penalty occurs on the play, there will be an untimed down.

But the only instance when a defense would accept a penalty rather than simply letting the game end would be if the offense scored on the play. Otherwise, there is absolutely no benefit to accepting.
Click to expand...
Do you mean this rule where it clearly says that on an offensive penalty on the last play, the down is not replayed and the play is nullified. NFL Rules Digest: Foul on Last Play of Half or Game
 
  • Like
Reactions: 5 people
#38
#38
Guys knee was down...then refs review a block in the back and pick up the flag. And I thought the targeting call on us was bad!
 
#40
#40
bamawriter said:
The foul was following a change of possession. So even in the NFL, Miami would have had an untimed down.
Click to expand...
OK. You didn't write that in your first post. You made a blanket statement attributing to all last plays in a game. Still not sure a kickoff is considered one of those "change of possession" situations. But, oh well. Not going to research it anymore.

Last block to me at around the 25 was the only clear block in the back I saw. Its too bad, because it should have been called and was completely unnecessary. The runner was 15 yards in front and near the end zone.
 
#42
#42
CSsc-V_VEAAATpG.jpg


lol
 
#45
#45
ZZ13 said:
Last block to me at around the 25 was the only clear block in the back I saw. Its too bad, because it should have been called and was completely unnecessary. The runner was 15 yards in front and near the end zone.
Click to expand...

Agreed. I just don't see how the refs are going to justify overturning it on review.
 
#48
#48
The difference between NCAA officiating and NFL officiating is the difference between NBA basketball vs. Women's Middle School Basketball. Every single ref in division 1 should be fired after this season. Biggest bunch of amateurs I've ever seen.
 
New posts
You must log in or register to reply here.

VN Store



Back
Top