Most over and under rated college football teams of last 10 years.

#1
McDad

McDad

I can't brain today; I has the dumb.
Joined
Jan 3, 2011
Messages
56,104
Likes
117,396
#1
We frequently complain about all those teams which are always pumped in the preseason only to flunk out in the final rankings. Let's test your acumen.
Each list has 24 spots:
1. Over the last 10 years which teams have consistently been ranked higher in the pre compared to their final ranking?

2. Same question on the reverse, which are consistently ranked lower in the pre compared to final?


Source (DON"T CHEAT): https://www.actionnetwork.com/ncaaf...ted-college-football-teams-preseason-rankings
 
#2
#2
Notre Dame absolutely has to be in the top 10 most overrated. I'd say Texas is there too, as is probably USC.

Underrated is harder. Wisconsin comes to mind.

Edit - I clicked the source. To not spoil it for everyone else, the position of one of the teams I mentioned is very surprising.
 
  • Like
Reactions: McDad
#3
#3
I’d put LSU & Texas A&M on the over in addition to ND and Texas. Ole Miss on the under.

Shot in the dark, Iowa on the under.
 
  • Like
Reactions: McDad
#4
#4
05_never_again said:
Notre Dame absolutely has to be in the top 10 most overrated. I'd say Texas is there too, as is probably USC.

Underrated is harder. Wisconsin comes to mind.

Edit - I clicked the source. To not spoil it for everyone else, the position of one of the teams I mentioned is very surprising.
Click to expand...
Good instincts. I was surprised by both lists but more surprised by the under rated list.
 
#5
#5
Maybe we can keep a running tally once correct guesses are made
Over:
1. Auburn
2. USC
3. Wisconsin
4. TAMU
5. LSU
6. Texas
7. Oregon
8. Oklahoma
9. Miami
10. FSU
11. Clemson
12. Stanford
13. Michigan State
14. Georgia
15. UCLA
16. South Carolina
17. ND
17. Alabama
18. Ohio State
19. North Carolina
22. Iowa State
23. Arkansas
24. Nebraska
24. Michigan

Under:
1. Northwestern
2. Cincinnati
3. TCU
4. Missouri
5. Kentucky
6. UCF
7. Houston
7. Ok State
7. Arizona
7. Louisiana
11. Tulane
12. Navy
13. West Virginia
14. Miss state
15. Kansas state
16. Coastal Carolina
17. Western Michigan
17. Minnesota
17. Syracuse
17. Wake Forest
21. Iowa
21. Fresno State
21. Liberty
24. Colorado
24. Georgia Tech
24. Indiana
24. Washington
 
Last edited:
#8
#8
Florida on the over

*I had USC but saw it was already on there lol
 
Last edited:
#12
#12
Thinking of coaches who can make something out of nothing, I'd say OK St. and Miss St. (RIP Coach Leach) probably were on the underrated list. Though it would be hard to argue with where they were rated preseason based on talent levels. Maybe TCU fits that category too during this window, but I really can't remember if they were ranked up high early or not generally. It seems natural to see them at the top by this point, so probably not.

I'm thinking may Clemson is kind on the overrated side of this since their great QBs left for the NFL. Lots of talent for underwhelming results.
 
#16
#16
Rifleman said:
Thinking of coaches who can make something out of nothing, I'd say OK St. and Miss St. (RIP Coach Leach) probably were on the underrated list. Though it would be hard to argue with where they were rated preseason based on talent levels. Maybe TCU fits that category too during this window, but I really can't remember if they were ranked up high early or not generally. It seems natural to see them at the top by this point, so probably not.

I'm thinking may Clemson is kind on the overrated side of this since their great QBs left for the NFL. Lots of talent for underwhelming results.
Click to expand...
7 and 14 and 3
 
  • Like
Reactions: Rifleman
#22
#22
Not listing ones already mentioned.

As much as I hate to say it, I'd say Missouri on the under. Washington on the under.

Oklahoma the last few years on the over. Miami on the over. This is a stab, because I can't remember how they rank preseason, but Kentucky on the over.
 
  • Like
Reactions: McDad
#23
#23
I don't think I got a single under rated lol. Lot's of surprises there.

I'm only surprised be like 2-3 of the overs.
 
  • Like
Reactions: McDad
#24
#24
Godfatha said:
Not listing ones already mentioned.

As much as I hate to say it, I'd say Missouri on the under. Washington on the under.

Oklahoma the last few years on the over. Miami on the over. This is a stab, because I can't remember how they rank preseason, but Kentucky on the over.
Click to expand...
4 and 24

ok at 8
 
  • Like
Reactions: Godfatha
#25
#25
Also its the past 10 years, so there's a lot of recency bias for me(I can only really remember the last 3-4 at best).
 
  • Like
Reactions: Rifleman
New posts
You must log in or register to reply here.

VN Store



Back
Top