So you're saying that there are zero factors that can be exhibited to determine whether a coach could be successful at any level?
Posted via VolNation Mobile
I'm saying the factors are not guarantees.
Winning percentage? Pearl had and has that in spades, and yet most of this site thinks he's a terrible coach. Even his fans are split on whether he's a good coach, recruiter, or motivator...his detractors think he's none of those.
Recruiting? If you're getting a mid-major coach, they've never competed with Kentucky or UNC for recruits, or even Georgia or Flipping Auburn.
Program management? Probably yes, you can tell that. Dennis Felton probably managed his program just fine, which got him a Georgia gig. He also recruited Thompkins and Leslie to it. Unfortunately, he couldn't coach with the big boys, and was a 6th-place finisher nearly every year.
Compounding all this is the fact that the whole thing is politicized, and the AD is making the decision, and he might not know a thing about basketball, and he himself is being pressured behind the scenes by donors, who may have wildly differing opinions themselves.