You wouldn't consider Butch Jones an "up and comer"?
Also on the Auburn thing...think of it like this. What if Cutcliffe left after 1998 NC season and PF was canned in year 2000? Then Cut comes back in 2001. He would probably have a similar record as Auburn.
Malzahn was gone only 1 year. So it would be like Fulmer being canned in after the '99 season and Cut coming back to take over in 2000, with even more of his original recruits. Not trying to diminish Malzahn at all, he's done great. But, as you were illustrating, it's an apples and oranges comparison given that Auburn is 3 years removed from a NC and that Malzahn is now working with guys he recruited to fit his system 2-4 years ago.