rank the current SEC head football coaches in order from Best to Worst

[Billy Costigan]

1)Les Miles
2)Nick Saban
3)Steve Spurrier
4)Bobby Petrino
5)James Franklin
6)Gene Chizik
7)Mark Richdt
8)Dan Mullen
9)Will Muschamp
10)Derek Dooley
11)Houston Nutt*
12)Joker Phillips

*fired

 

[Pulscifer]

James Franklin at 5...are you serious?

1. Saban
2. Miles
3. Petrino
4. Richt
5. Spurrier
6. Chizik
7. Mullen
8. Muschamp
9. Franklin
9. Dooley
11. Phillips

 

[UTK]

1. Dooley.

 

[txvolsfangatorh8r]

James Franklin at 5...are you serious?

1. Saban
2. Miles
3. Petrino
4. Richt
5. Spurrier
6. Chizik
7. Mullen
8. Muschamp
9. Franklin
9. Dooley
11. Phillips

agree except you should switch richt and spurrier. when mark can beat him, then he should be ranked ahead

 

[iuvol2012]

1)Les Miles
2)Nick Saban
3)Steve Spurrier
4)Bobby Petrino
5)James Franklin
6)Gene Chizik
7)Mark Richdt
8)Dan Mullen
9)Will Muschamp
10)Derek Dooley
11)Houston Nutt*
12)Joker Phillips

*fired

1) Nick Saban
2) Les Miles
3) Bobby Petrino
4) Steve Spurrier
5) Mark Richt
6) Dan Mullen
7) Gene Chizik
8) Will Muschamp
9) Hugh Freeze
10) James Franklin
11) Joker Phillips
12) Derek Dooley

Just my two cents.

 

[Volture]

1. Dooley.

true fan is true

 

[Billy Costigan]

I think Franklin is a real good Coach.

 

[UTCVol]

Saban
Miles
Petrino
Richt
Spurrier
Pinkel
Chizik
Mullen
Freeze
Muschamp
Dooley
Franklin
Phillips

 

[milohimself]

Saban
Miles
Spurrier
Petrino
Richt
Chizik
Mullen
Muschamp
Franklin
Dooley
Phillips

Left Freeze/OM off

 

[Through_The_T]

Saban
Miles
Spurrier
Richt
Petrino
Chizik
Mullen
Franklin
Muschamp
Dooley
Phillips

Freeze left out...

 

[zjcvols]

saban
miles
petrino
richt
spurrier
pinkel
chizik
mullen
freeze
muschamp
dooley
franklin
phillips

lol

 

[jguy2]

Looking at Spurrier's entire body of work, Saban is the only guy I could put in front of him. USCe is starting to improve under Spurrier the last couple of seasons, and there's no denying that what he did at Florida was anything less than incredible. Six conference championships, including 4 back to back, and a national championship. He won a minimum of 9 games every season there and had 9 ten win seasons out of his twelve years there.

Saban seems to have success everywhere he goes, that's pretty obvious. While Les Miles is having a great run at LSU, his time at OSU wasn't anything to be proud of.

1.) Saban
2.) Spurrier
3.) Miles
4.) Richt
5.) Petrino
6.) Chizik
7.) Muschamp
8.) Dooley
9.) Franklin
10.) Mullen
11.) Phillips
12.) Nutt

 

[YankeeVol]

Saban
Miles
Spurrier
Petrino
Chizik
Richt
Mullen
Pinkel
Muschamp
Franklin
Phillips
Freeze
A&Ms CTBD
Dooley

 

[Wylo]

Saban
Miles
Spurrier
Petrino
Chizik
Richt
Mullen
Pinkel
Muschamp
Franklin
Phillips
Freeze
A&Ms CTBD
Dooley

I like this. I see what you did there..

 

[bleedorange0037]

1)Les Miles
2)Nick Saban
3)Steve Spurrier
4)Bobby Petrino
5)James Franklin
6)Gene Chizik
7)Mark Richdt
8)Dan Mullen
9)Will Muschamp
10)Derek Dooley
11)Houston Nutt*
12)Joker Phillips

*fired

Don't really see how you can rank Joker Phillips behind DD when he just outcoached him so badly that he was able to beat him with ridiculously inferior talent and no QB.

For me the list as of now is

1. Miles (only because he always gets the breaks, and it's good to have a guy like that on your side)
2. Saban
3. Petrino
4. Richt
5. Spurrier
6. Chizik
7. Mullen
8. Franklin
9. Muschamp
10. Phillips
11. Dooley

 

[BeecherVol]

1. Miles
2. Saban
3. Spurrier
4. Petrino
5. Richt
6. Chizik
7. Mullen
8. Franklin
9. Muschamp
10. Dooley
11. Phillips

 

[DrunkJohnny]

1. Miles
2. Saban
3. Petrino
4. Spurrier
5. Chizik
6. Richt
7. Mullen
8. Muschamp
9. Dooley
10. Franklin
11. Phillips

 

[rockyvols]

1. Dooley.

Amen

 

[golfballs]

1)Nick Saban
2)Les Miles
3)Steve Spurrier
4)Bobby Petrino
5)Gene Chizik
6)Mark Richt
7)James Franklin
8)Dan Mullen
9)Derek Dooley
10)Will Muschamp
11)Houston Nutt
12)Joker Phillips

With the talent that Florida has, there is zero reason for their 500 record. So far Muschamp has not impressed me in the least.

 

[lawgator1]

1)Nick Saban
2)Les Miles
3)Steve Spurrier
4)Bobby Petrino
5)Gene Chizik
6)Mark Richt
7)James Franklin
8)Dan Mullen
9)Derek Dooley
10)Will Muschamp
11)Houston Nutt
12)Joker Phillips

With the talent that Florida has, there is zero reason for their 500 record. So far Muschamp has not impressed me in the least.

Stupid because Muschamp is 1-0 against Dooley.

Having said that, I am tempted to agree we should be better than .500, but note that we lost our starting QB for some critical games, i.e. the close loss to Auburn. Plus we had over a dozen open scholarships this year -- the depth just wasn't there.

Can't stand the lack of discipline on the field, however. If that continues next year, the ouster contingent will have my vote, fwiw.

 

[BearCat204]

1)Dooley
2-12) errbody else.............

 

[golfballs]

Stupid because Muschamp is 1-0 against Dooley.

Having said that, I am tempted to agree we should be better than .500, but note that we lost our starting QB for some critical games, i.e. the close loss to Auburn. Plus we had over a dozen open scholarships this year -- the depth just wasn't there.

Can't stand the lack of discipline on the field, however. If that continues next year, the ouster contingent will have my vote, fwiw.

1 head-to-head game doesn't mean a lot to me in terms of coaching ability. And your injury excuse could easily be applied to that matchup too since Hunter got hurt. Game changer, IMO. But Florida still has legions of more talent than Tennessee.

 

[Jax_Vol]

1)Nick Saban
2)Les Miles
3)Steve Spurrier
4)Bobby Petrino
5)Gene Chizik
6)Mark Richt
7)James Franklin
8)Dan Mullen
9)Derek Dooley
10)Will Muschamp
11)Houston Nutt
12)Joker Phillips

With the talent that Florida has, there is zero reason for their 500 record. So far Muschamp has not impressed me in the least.

Yes, I fully agree with that...anyone who takes Florida talent and has a .500 record is one incredibly bad coach. Florida has the best high school system in the country. Getting some of their talent is a staple for probably fifty Division I football programs. For the state school of Florida to only beat Vandy, UT, Kentucky & three non-conference cupcakes is incredible. Thank goodness for Muschamp! I hope they keep him there for a decade.

1) Nick Saban
2) Steve Spurrier
3) Les Miles
4) Gene Chizik
5) Bobby Petrino
6) James Franklin
7) Derek Dooley
8) Mark Richt
9) Dan Mullin
10) Houston Nutt
11) Joker Phillips
12) Will Muschamp

 

[Pulscifer]

Yes, I fully agree with that...anyone who takes Florida talent and has a .500 record is one incredibly bad coach. Florida has the best high school system in the country. Getting some of their talent is a staple for probably fifty Division I football programs. For the state school of Florida to only beat Vandy, UT, Kentucky & three non-conference cupcakes is incredible. Thank goodness for Muschamp! I hope they keep him there for a decade.

1) Nick Saban
2) Steve Spurrier
3) Les Miles
4) Gene Chizik
5) Bobby Petrino
6) James Franklin
7) Derek Dooley
8) Mark Richt
9) Dan Mullin
10) Houston Nutt
11) Joker Phillips
12) Will Muschamp

Dooley and Franklin ahead of Richt? :crazy:

 

[TennesseeFan07]

Are we ranking the best coaches in the present or overall resumes?