Maybe Maddux just really always sucked and nobody knew it...
Which is absolute pure
...look all I know is he got squeezed and it was obvious, you can't make me believe he just suddenly lost control every October....the freaking umps suddenly decided to change what they called balls and strikes when he was pitching.
As far as John Smoltz goes...Smoltzie was a power pitcher, so that didn't bother him and pitchers like him as much, it was devastating to a finesse pitcher like Maddux.
And as far as answering that question, I've already said right off the bat...I have NEVER understood it.