I’ve had Weller Special Reserve, Antique 107, and Weller 12. Gets better as you move to the right on the list. But not a Weller fan. It’s wheated and I’m not fond of wheated bourbons.
Have open bottles of Barrel Dovetail and Thomas Handy Sazerac Rye. Handy may be my favorite. Have unopened bottles of Booker’s 2202-01 (Ronnie’s Batch), Garrison Bros. Balmorhea, and Garrison Bros. Cowboy bourbon. Saving those for special occasions. Have already downed a bottle of the Booker‘s and the Balmorhea. Yum.
You previously mentioned the Old Forrester line. My favorites are 1920, Statesman, then 1910. 1897 is okay but nothing to write home about.
EH Taylor is solid. George T Stagg is also good. Elmer T Lee is great if you can find it.
1792 is a good pour. 1792 bottled in bond is really good. Heaven’s Hill bottled in bond is exceptional if you can find it.
Haven’t had Jefferson’s Reserve. Have had Jefferson Ocean. No big deal.
For the budget minded, try Russell’s Reserve 10 year. Jimmy Russell is the Master Distiller for the Wild Turkey family. Rare Breed is also good.
My go to for an average price is Noah’s Mill. It’s a Willett product.
There are so many good bourbons and ryes. I’m trying to make my way thru as many as I can.