It boggles my mind that somewhere on the East Coast can’t build a stadium at least somewhat comparable. Columbus, GA is just a couple hours from where I live. It’s home to the ‘96 Olympic softball complex. Aside from the GHSA championships and maybe a few tournaments here and there, it’s not really used. I hate that. It’s got potential for sure, given the fact it has the logistics and the history.
That aside, surely somewhere in Atlanta, a softball hotspot, or somewhere in Florida (especially on the Space Coast where the USSSA Pride was located or on the Emerald Coast, given the Clearwater Invitational) could make a go at it. Probably some other spots, too. Those are just the big 3 that come to mind because of my personal proximity.
I have traveled with Tennessee to five of their eight trips to the Women’s College World Series, so let me share a little insight on the topic from that perspective.
Does Oklahoma have a home-field advantage? Yes, but not nearly to the level that people think. It’s a close drive for Oklahoma fans, but it’s also a close drive for Oklahoma State fans. The stadium is not filled to the brim with just OU fans, if you’ve ever been to the World Series, the crowd is made up of a ton of youth teams and travel ball teams because the city has big events for both all week long. Oklahoma City began hosting the event in 1990, and Oklahoma didn’t win its first championship until the year 2000. They didn’t win a second until 2013. In my opinion, from being deeply involved in the sport, Oklahoma’s run of national championships has exactly zero to do with where the WCWS is held.
Several places bid on it the last time it was up for bid, but Oklahoma City won the bid, not just because of the facility and the money and the promises of continued stadium upgrades just for Softball, but also because of the dozens of related events that the city puts on every year for travel teams that make the WCWS more than just a championship event.
You also have the factor of the number of full service hotels in downtown OKC that all clear out to host teams. I’ve been to a lot of NCAA championships with various teams, and I’ve never seen a place that embraces the event and its teams like Oklahoma City does for the WCWS. I’ve heard that Omaha for baseball is very similar, but I’ve never been. One of the things the NCAA looks for when they award a championship event to a city, whether it’s a long-term contract like OKC and Omaha have, or individual years for the final four in basketball or volleyball or whatever is that a city is willing to commit to giving to athletes and fans a total experience. Making them feel like they are at a big time event from the second plane lands until the second they depart. They want a city that will put up signs, that will have special events, that will welcome teams and fans with focus on them where the city is about the event for the week, rather than just an event that is occurring in their city.
The places you mentioned are fine, but none of them have a 15,000 seat stadium just for Softball. The place where they hold the Clearwater invitational barely holds 1000 fans and is a logistical nightmare for both teams and fans. Hoover, Alabama bid on it last time around, intending to put it in the baseball stadium where they host the SEC tournament. That was really the only other competitive bid because of stadium size and team amenities. One thing that hurt the Hoover bid was the hotel/downtown factor. Although downtown OKC is a 20 minute drive from Hall of Fame Stadium, you’re able to put most of the teams and fans in one area so it feels like a big event from the moment they land until the moment they leave. Hoover doesn’t have that, and you would have teams staying as far away downtown Birmingham. It just didn’t meet the “big time feel“ that the NCAA looks for in championship event sites.
Finally, we can have this debate all we want, but the current contract with Hall of Fame Stadium in Oklahoma City runs through 2035, so there are at least 11 more events to be held there before it could possibly move.