Tee Martin/Vince Young

[hatvol96]

Then shouldn't his stats be better this year instead of a mirror image of his last season in the cultural disaster known as Nashville?

No, he's a year older with declining skills. If he had played for the Titans this year, he would have looked like Joe Namath with the Rams.

 

[kptvol]

He did.

Young:
15 G, 51.5%, 2199 yards, 6.16 ypa, 12 TD, 13 INT, 66.7 rating, 552 yards rushing

Leinart:
12 G, 56.8%, 2547 yards, 6.76 ypa, 11 TD, 12 INT, 74.0 rating, 49 yards rushing

Leinart clearly had the better year.

Leinart's wide receivers are about 20x better than Young's, however.

 

[tidwell]

No, he's a year older with declining skills. If he had played for the Titans this year, he would have looked like Joe Namath with the Rams.

Still an improvement over Kyle Boller and Anthony Wright... do you think he'll hinder their chances of going to the Super Bowl? I still think he can be solid enough along with Lewis and that defense to make it out of the AFC.

Leinart's wide receivers are about 20x better than Young's, however.

The Titans #1 WR might be good enough to be the #3 for the Cardinals. I say might because I have no idea who is the #3 WR for the Cardinals.

 

[hatvol96]

Still an improvement over Kyle Boller and Anthony Wright... do you think he'll hinder their chances of going to the Super Bowl? I still think he can be solid enough along with Lewis and that defense to make it out of the NFC.


The Titans #1 WR might be good enough to be the #3 for the Cardinals. I say might because I have no idea who is the #3 WR for the Cardinals.

1. I think obtaining McNair is the only reason they're in the playoffs. They would have no shot at the Super Bowl with Boller or Wright.
2. Bryant Johnson would probably be the Titans best receiver. Everytime one of the Cardinals' big two get hurt, Johnson excels.

 

[mattvols]

Young has a better arm then Tee did. Tee could throw the long ball but lacked touch on his midrange ball.

 

[GAVol]

How did you get to be such a great QB evaluator at the age of 9?

 

[blaker024]

He did.

Young:
15 G, 51.5%, 2199 yards, 6.16 ypa, 12 TD, 13 INT, 66.7 rating, 552 yards rushing

Leinart:
12 G, 56.8%, 2547 yards, 6.76 ypa, 11 TD, 12 INT, 74.0 rating, 49 yards rushing

Leinart clearly had the better year.

First of all, you're giving me stats instead of wins. Second of all, those stats actually aren't that different. So I don't think that you can say "clearly" as you so eloquently put it.

 

[VolinArizona]

It's not that clear from your numbers.

Plus I believe Young had a better record.

I believe the Titans had a better record than the Cardinals.

If you all are going to start using VY's "wins" as to why he's better, then you're going to have to start saying Peyton Manning isn't the best QB in the league. Can't have it both ways.

 

[VolinArizona]

First of all, you're giving me stats instead of wins. Second of all, those stats actually aren't that different. So I don't think that you can say "clearly" as you so eloquently put it.

Alright, then Trent Dilfer is better than Peyton Manning.