Tony- Your buddy's cat is incredible. That's an extremely nice fish and catching one of those is an awesome accomplishment.
How often do you guys go? I always here that fishing for cats at night is a myth, but I continue to hear stories that it's better at night.
Well, my buddy Matt goes a lot more than I do. He lives not to far away from the lake. I live 35-40 minute drive. I don't go as often but I also have some health issues that keep from going more than I want.
Catfish will bite both day & night. It depends more on what time of the years it is. Like I said in one of my previous post, our 2 catfish holes have biting frenzy's at different times of the year including day & night. Right now, they bite in the evening just til shortly after dark.
There's about a 2-3 hour window & then the bite is over. Say from 8PM in the evening til 10:30-11:00PM. After that time it shuts off almost like a light switch. This will go on until about the middle of July.
Then, the bite starts after dark & last up until 3-4 AM. This is when you hit the primetime for a huge catfish. From middle July-middle September. Live bluegills, Live shiners,& even a hook loaded with gobs on nightcrawlers can get you hooked into some huge catfish.
It's fun because you don't ever know if it's going to be a flathead or Bluecat. The Blucat seem to not go after the Live bluegills too much. They like the large shiners & gobs of nightcrawlers better. The Blucat do put up a better fight than a Flathead.
Once October hits it's again like a light switch. They completely stop biting usually after that first real serious cold front that drops the overnight temps in the 30's. No more biting catfish from these 2 spots again until the next year rolls around starting in mid-late April.