Ummm, no. None of that was true of that post.
Dooley inherited a train wreck. It would have been a near miracle had he survived. But it was his choice. He was a beaten, broken coach by Vandy '12. No question.
But if you really want to consider "flawed reasoning"... you need look no further than your insenuation that he purposely came back to frustrate you with a bad lose to Vandy. Talk about egocentric delusion....
Now we truly have seen a miracle. The recruiting services were right about everyone else's 4* recruits... but almost uniformly wrong about UT's.
Since we don't have Feldman's direct quotes... and you seem intent on bending things to suit you... I can't answer that part except to only say that it is difficult to tell very much from a team playing itself.
However, Dooley inherited NO QB's... SEC ready or otherwise.
Dooley inherited ONE RB with any kind of SEC experience.
Dooley inherited LESS talent at WR than Jones but more experience.
The biggest difference on O is/was the OL. The only OL DD inherited was a guy who was beaten out the previous year by the Sullins bros. Otherwise, he started freshmen. Those Fr are now Srs. Four plus Tiny who may go early will be in the NFL draft. That's a HUGE difference.
On D, DD only inherited one SEC worthy DE and he had a beat up body. His best DT was a DE transfer. Fact is... he HAD NO DT's on the roster. Jones has 4 or 5 guys with SEC level talent. He has some DE's with SEC level talent and especially if he moves Maggitt.
Unless once again EVERYONE lied during the recruitment of the guys playing DB at UT... they have speed. Sunseri's confusion definitely had them playing slow. That does not mean they are slow.
LB is thin on the outside. DD recruited for the 3-4... sort of. That is a significant area of concern.
They have holes. That's true. But they are nothing compared to 3 years ago. You can delude yourself if you like but Dooley literally inherited a team without talent and experience and often without both.
No. You don't. They better coach those guys up and make it work. Somehow again... some guys that many high level programs seemed to want don't have talent?
After 3 years, DD's team was more talented and deeper. He was fired explicitly because he could not take a team with good depth and actually some outstanding talent... and win. In fact, he lost games he should not have lost.
Dooley was not fired because he could not recruit or could not manage a program. He did a pretty decent job of both. He was fired because the guy lacks the skill or maybe the talent to be a head coach.
The roster is not what we would hope for but it is MILES ahead of what it was 3 years ago in every respect.
Absolutely delusional. Knew I shouldn't have tried. Good thing you weren't in Guyana with Jim Jones. #KoolAid