The Supreme Court of the United States Thread

because cancer surgery wasn't illegal in TN. what's been floated is the idea of preventing a state citizen from going elsewhere to do something illegal in said state. won't hold up but doesn't mean that it hasn't already been considered.
I think you're assuming too much when you say it won't hold up. The conservative justices are no less motivated by partisan ideology than the liberal ones.
 
If any republicans had any foresight, they'd realize they just opened the doors to lose midterms and state elections.

Not if they just take the win and leave it up to the states. If they can break the pattern of self inflicted wounds (doubt they can) then this ruling will not hurt them in the least.
 
Had to with right to privacy which while not expressed in that term exactly, exists in for example the right to be secure in your person or home. Thomas .... I don't know what to say. He's out there. On the extreme of the extreme. What he's talking about overruling is indescribable in its breadth.
Right to privacy was the argument used for the Roe V. Wade decision, right? I've always been of the opinion the 10th Amendment should take precedence and it should be a state issue, not a federal one. That does not mean I think states should be outlawing abortion. If a state makes an unpopular decision, it is up to the constituents of that state to vote for new government that will enact their wishes.
 
Now watch the radicals allow up to birth procedures
disguting
Now hold on here. Seriously.

Should “the radicals” in Oregon be allowed to let the people of their State decide Oregon Law?

This is what State’s Rights is all about.

If you are Ok with Mississippi deciding what’s right for Mississippi, but not Ok with Oregon deciding what’s right for Oregon - are you saying you want the Federal Government to decide?
 
If any republicans had any foresight, they'd realize they just opened the doors to lose midterms and state elections.
You know there is a large portion of women who are happy about this decision? My wife is ecstatic about it.

Having said that, I agree with a number of posters. The Republicans have everything going their way and they are bound to screw it up. It's like they cannot help themselves.
 

VN Store



Back
Top