AllVol11717
Well-Known Member
- Joined
- Apr 23, 2011
- Messages
- 3,210
- Likes
- 4,943
I don’t entirely disagree, but it even more muddies the water of evaluating the HC position if certain coaches are only good coaches in specific situations.I think Butch would be a good coach on a small stage. There was too much pressure on the big stage for him. I think coaching here, broke him. KS walked into a perfect situation for any coach. Stocked cupboards and willingness to skirt the rules. We got the exact opposite with cornbread.
Jimbo spent a boat load of money to get the best players and still couldn't win because he didn't spend enough on a QB. He had defense and WR, RB, but QB he went bargain bin.
I tend to believe that a good coach is someone that can make his team consistently competitive at whatever level of competition they’re playing.
It just seems wiser to hold off on declaring coaches good OR bad without sizable data to prove otherwise. The fact is most coaches are average. It’s an incredibly difficult job to separate yourself from the pack which is why they’re paid so well but also fired in such large numbers annually.