As an initial recruit? It shouldn't be surprising. Less than half of any given draft will be made up of guys rated 4/5* as HS recruits. They hit a pretty high percentage of those they give 5* but miss a lot on 4*.For all the talk about Neyor being elite, 247 did not rate him accordingly. A 4 star, and not a very highly ranked one. Surprising.
This is by design. If they actually attempted to find and correctly rate every kid with actual 4* talent... they would laughed at. By limiting the number of 4/5* ratings they hand out, the create an illusion of being "accurate".