Could not disagree with the two of you more.
First, we're not a paper tiger, in any form or fashion. A paper tiger is, "something or someone that claims or appears to be powerful or threatening but is actually ineffectual and unable to withstand challenge." So you both think we're unable to withstand challenge? We're 8-1, dudes. Including wins over five SEC teams. Say what you want about Kentucky or Mississippi State, every SEC contest is a challenge. The Bama game doesn't count as a challenge to you? Because that's the only way we even come close to the definition of "paper tiger." We're friggin' 8-1. Sheesh.
And second, we're not "searching for our identity." The identity of this team is well established by now: crushingly stingy on defense, and a bit Jeckyl & Hyde on offense (September was huge points, like 50/game, October was low points, like 20/game, and November is too early to tell). That's who we are. Great D, schizophrenic O with a young QB.
It makes one think you each just reached out, grabbed a random cliche, and tried to apply it to our team.
Go Vols!