Gee whiz, Buckeyes have outspoken prez
July 17, 2006 by
rmelick@bhamnews.com.
When former Vanderbilt Chancellor Gordon Gee was introduced as the new president of Ohio State University last week, it had the feel of an athletic version of "Mr. Smith Goes To Washington."
That is, if Mr. Smith was going back to Washington after having been voted out of office once for being a fiscal conservative in an era of government big spending.
Faithful followers of NCAA reform recognize Gee as the man best known for having done away with Vanderbilt's athletic department, placing the operation of big-time intercollegiate athletics under the auspices of the university's Department of Student Life.
While that move may have been as much about cutting costs at Vanderbilt as it was making an athletic reform statement, it made Gee a hero among those who believe football, in particular, has become the tail that wags the collegiate dog.
And it is a reputation Gee took advantage of. He became an outspoken critic of academic abuses in college athletics, supporting the idea of tying athletic scholarships to graduation rates.
He's spoken out against the escalating costs of doing NCAA business, publicly pointing out that while he was the highest paid university president in the country, earning an estimated $1.2 million a year according to a survey done by the Chronicle of Higher Education, he was still making only one-fourth the money of the highest paid college football coach in the country.
We all know who he was referring to, don't we?
Now Gee, who was Ohio State's president from 1990 to 1997, is going back to Columbus to oversee a university whose athletic department's budget is the largest in the country, over $100 million a year.
Some wonder if this might be the equivalent of putting the rooster in charge of the fox den; of having Newt Gingrich manage Hillary Clinton's presidential campaign; of asking Phyllis Schlafly to take over NOW.
Mike Cleary, the executive director of the National Association for Collegiate Directors of Athletics, was quoted, "When it comes to intercollegiate athletics, Dr. Gee's just a loose cannon."
In silencing Florida President Bernie Machen's move for a playoff, Gee said, "We've been consistent all along that we're trying to bring some semblance of integrity and some semblance of balance into what we're doing, and this moves in exactly the wrong direction.
"This is a slippery slope toward us finally just throwing in the towel and saying what we're about is fielding football teams and we have a university on the side, and I'm just not in favor of that."
In an interview with the Cleveland Plain Dealer, Gee added, "I am a great believer in intercollegiate athletics. I think it's broken. ..."
Which sounds great when you're the chancellor at Vanderbilt. But at Ohio State, where dotting the "i" at a football game is considered one of the highest honors the school can bestow?
The podium from which Gee will speak at Ohio State is much larger than the one he had at Vanderbilt, and has the chance to carry far more weight.
But then, the fervor that is Buckeye athletics is much greater, too.
And many on both sides of the athletic reform movement are anxious to see whether Gee loses his voice, or simply changes his tune.
Ray Melick's column appears Tuesday, Thursday and Saturday. Write him at
rmelick@bhamnews.com.
© 2007 The Birmingham News