Who is the better Manning?

[Reformed Reader]

I wanted to get everyone's thoughts

 

[Lexvol]

Cooper. Next question.

 

[005]

Peyton.

/thread

 

[SDV]

Danny

 

[BeecherVol]

Cooper. Next question.

Archie

You lose.

 

[Berry4Heisman14]

This is going to get ugly OP.....very ugly.

 

[UTCVol]

Ricky.

 

[tim]

Give Peyton the Giants defense and we would be talking best qb ever.

 

[ThunderSK]

Peyton, wish he would've had a defense to support him most of his career

 

[DjCrenshaw]

Peyton, but I'm a homer

 

[LittleCat]

As of now...Eli.

 

[Volgrad98]

Since everyone always talks championships, Eli. 2 is better than 1, right?

 

[JonWard]

better in what?? current or historical?

In some things Eli is better, and in others, Peyton.

Eli has more rings. I think if you polled NFL players, Peyon wins out, although Eli is now in the Hall of Fame with this win.

 

[vol-un-tear]

Right now Eli. 2 for 2 in Super Bowls. I hope Peyton gets another shot.

 

[JonWard]

As of now...Eli.

Currently? no question.

 

[GetEmVols]

Peyton of course. Qbs are not measured
by superbowl rings. Is Joseph addai better than Arian foster? He has more superbowl rings! You can't compare superbowl rings with individual players to determine skill. Team effort.

Next question.

 

[badkarma]

Seriously?

 

[GAVol]

Since everyone always talks championships, Eli. 2 is better than 1, right?

That means Trent Dilfer is better than Dan Marino and Jim Kelly.

 

[LittleCat]

All-time? Hard to say. Peyton maybe. But Eli close.

 

[005]

That means Trent Dilfer is better than Dan Marino and Jim Kelly.

Yeah, that gets really dumb really quickly.

 

[vollygirl]

As far as a football mind goes, Peyton. And it's not close.

 

[GetEmVols]

That means Trent Dilfer is better than Dan Marino and Jim Kelly.

^ beautiful.

 

[TrueOrange]

Peyton



Teams win championships

 

[Volgrad98]

Peyton of course. Qbs are not measured
by superbowl rings. Is Joseph addai better than Arian foster? He has more superbowl rings! You can't compare superbowl rings with individual players to determine skill. Team effort.

Next question.

I would have used Barry Sanders in my argument, but I get what you are saying.

 

[Volgrad98]

That means Trent Dilfer is better than Dan Marino and Jim Kelly.

Of course.