Who is the better Manning?

#54
#54
I know one thing, Eli winning the Super Bowl MVP kinda makes you forget about his older brother Clayton
 
  • Like
Reactions: 3 people
#56
#56
mchandl7 said:
Peyton had a head start and plays in one of the weakest divisions in the NFL. Eli plays in one of the two toughest divisions.
Click to expand...

Giants won their division with a 9-7 record.

Peyton made playoffs as one of the top teams everytime. He would have won any division most times he made playoffs.
 
#63
#63
altidore17 said:
Who were the back ups besides the QB position? Patriots went 11-5 without Tom Brady. Colts go 2-14.
Click to expand...

His backup just so happened to go on to get a starting job the next year.......is there a team on the planet that Painter should start for?
 
#65
#65
Currently? Peyton, Colts aren't even in Indianapolis if he's not there. Would love to see Peyton on a team with the Giant's defense.
 
#68
#68
altidore17 said:
And has had one of the best defenses in the NFL. Peyton has had absolutely ZERO help. ZERO.
Click to expand...

You are such a clueless homer. No help? Lmao.

He has had four first round RBs. Three first round WRs. A first round TE. The best pair of pass rushing DEs in the league.
Just shut up. You are so wrong it is not funny.

Eli is the answer to the OP question.

Peyton is a choke artist dating back to college.

When they won the superbowl it was because of his defense stepping up in the playoffs and the RBs were their offense in the superbowl win.
 
Last edited:
  • Like
Reactions: 1 person
#69
#69
AstonRoyal said:
Currently? Peyton, Colts aren't even in Indianapolis if he's not there. Would love to see Peyton on a team with the Giant's defense.
Click to expand...

He will be. He'll be a Jet next season! Manning brothers, Jets vs Giants Super Bowl in 2013 in the stadium they share. Place your bets now :)
 
#70
#70
WG53 said:
You are such a clueless homer. No help? Lmao.

He has had four first round RBs. Three first round WRs. A first round TE. The best pair of pass rushing DEs in the league.

Just shut up. You are so wrong it is not funny.
Click to expand...

I'm sure eli has the same amount of first round picks on his team? Higher first round picks, actually. Because Peyton won 12 games a year for forever.

Peyton's better. This is fun though.
 
#72
#72
WG53 said:
You are such a clueless homer. No help? Lmao.

He has had four first round RBs. Three first round WRs. A first round TE. The best pair of pass rushing DEs in the league.
Just shut up. You are so wrong it is not funny.

Eli is the answer to the OP question.

Peyton is a choke artist dating back to college.

When they won the superbowl it was because of his defense stepping up in the playoffs and the RBs were their offense in the superbowl win.
Click to expand...

Lulz shouldn't have edited the post.
 
#74
#74
WG53 said:
You are such a clueless homer. No help? Lmao.

He has had four first round RBs. Three first round WRs. A first round TE. The best pair of pass rushing DEs in the league.
Just shut up. You are so wrong it is not funny.

Eli is the answer to the OP question.

Peyton is a choke artist dating back to college.

When they won the superbowl it was because of his defense stepping up in the playoffs and the RBs were their offense in the superbowl win.
Click to expand...

:popcorn: wow
 
New posts
You must log in or register to reply here.

VN Store



Back
Top