Windy's football discussion thread.

[Behr]

 

[Behr]

https://bleacherreport.com/articles/10142046-cfb-playoff-picture-2024-25-bracket-projections-scenarios-after-week-11-ap-rankings

CFB Playoff Picture 2024-25: Bracket Projections, Scenarios After Week 11 AP Rankings​

 

[LouderVol]

Wrong angle to see the hit for determining targeting, but
1. Kentucky player struck with the crown of his helmet which knocked the ball out
2. KY player did impact K’s body with his own
3. That should have been called a TD. K had possession of the ball when it crossed the goal line and foot on the ground in the endzone when struck

you have to complete the catch, and maintain control of the ball. if that was a catch, it would have been a turnover & a touchback.

 

[GordonC]

tl;dr
7-1 in November for the second time in the past three seasons
really happy with where we are and with the culture of the program
so nice to be nationally relevant again, to be watching just about any game and we get mentioned in some positive context
more work to do this year, obviously, but feels great

ordered this today


GO VOLS

 

[theFallGuy]

https://bleacherreport.com/articles/10142046-cfb-playoff-picture-2024-25-bracket-projections-scenarios-after-week-11-ap-rankings

CFB Playoff Picture 2024-25: Bracket Projections, Scenarios After Week 11 AP Rankings​

View attachment 694132

I saw one predicting us playing Indiana and another predicting a game in South Bend. That would be classic

 

[Behr]

I saw one predicting us playing Indiana and another predicting a game in South Bend. That would be classic

Man, beat Joe's boys and the sky is the limit.

 

[Behr]

 

[BigOrangeMojo]

Not confusing that for SEC Shorts....

 

[Tin Man]

you have to complete the catch, and maintain control of the ball. if that was a catch, it would have been a turnover & a touchback.

My observation and argument are that K did complete the catch, possessing the ball across the goal line, and having foot contact with the ground in the endzone before he was struck by the defender. At that moment before impact, the requirements for a touchdown were met. Impact was after the fact. The consequence of the ball being knock free was moot.

 

[BigOrangeMojo]

Not a catch...

If that's one, then Jabar Gaffneys was as well...

 

[Behr]

Not confusing that for SEC Shorts....

You wanna a bozo button?

 

[82_VOL_83]

My observation and argument are that K did complete the catch, possessing the ball across the goal line, and having foot contact with the ground in the endzone before he was struck by the defender. At that moment before impact, the requirements for a touchdown were met. Impact was after the fact. The consequence of the ball being knock free was moot.

The replay from the correct angle showed it was a clean hit on the ball with the shoulder, at least IMO.

 

[BigOrangeMojo]

You wanna a bozo button?

Thanks for the offer but you can keep it or offer it to BOT....

 

[Behr]

Thanks for the offer but you can keep it or offer it to BOT....

I've got plenty because I learned that just because you dont except it don't mean you don't deserve it.

Edit to add after your edit: he's a lost cause.

 

[82_VOL_83]

@Orangeslice13 @BigOrangeMojo @GordonC

 

[Behr]

@Orangeslice13 @BigOrangeMojo @GordonC

Mojo ain't confusing that for SEC shorts.

 

[Tin Man]

The replay from the correct angle showed it was a clean hit on the ball with the shoulder, at least IMO.

So, no targeting. Glad you feel reassured about that.

 

[Tin Man]

OK, those of you who do not agree with my contention that a TD was achieved before the KY defender hit K and knocked the ball loose, cite the specific requirement(s) that you think were not met.

 

[82_VOL_83]

OK, those of you who do not agree with my contention that a TD was achieved before the KY defender hit K and knocked the ball loose, cite the specific requirement(s) that you think were not met.

He dropped the ball prior to making a football move. Didn't control the ball to the ground. Got his **** rocked and dropped it. It wasn't a ****ing catch.

 

[82_VOL_83]

Mojo ain't confusing that for SEC shorts.

I thought about the best refs going to Knoxville and KY complaining was funny.

 

[Behr]

Zone Football thread....

 

[GordonC]

OK, those of you who do not agree with my contention that a TD was achieved before the KY defender hit K and knocked the ball loose, cite the specific requirement(s) that you think were not met.

he didn't catch it
in no way did he make a football move while having possession
not close to being a catch

 

[GordonC]

also like Louder said, I mean if you rule it a catch, you'd have to rule it a fumble

 

[Behr]

I thought about the best refs going to Knoxville and KY complaining was funny.

Lulz, I still have no clue what he meant and now I have no clue what you mean. Imma take my Bozo button an gtfo.

 

[VolNExile]

Lulz, I still have no clue what he meant and now I have no clue what you mean. Imma take my Bozo button an gtfo.