Ultimately I agree, but when you need (or think you need) immediate help elite recruits are the recruits that give you instant hope. Fulkerson went through 2-3 seasons of people questioning his abilities before his breakout year. You can't always wait. It will all work itself out, I have no doubt.
Who were you more excited about committing to Tennessee, Jordan Bone or Kennedy Chandler? Bone was great for Tennessee, but it took a couple seasons for him to reach that level of play. With the "elite" recruits you're hopefully eliminating those first couple of adjustment years.
But just because you are highly rated like Renaldo Woolridge, Kenny Hall, DJ Burns Jordan McRae etc, it doesn't mean you will come in and have a major impact immediately. - All 4 stars, but not necessarily elite.