Madmartigan has always been a very level headed, respectful poster.
I'll break it down piece by piece to tell my opinion:
RBs: UT
I'd give us the advantage here based on the players alone, line play excluded. With Lane's overall experience, Hurd's combination of elusiveness, explosiveness, size, and speed, and the potential Derrell Scott has to be a secret weapon.
WRs: UT
Once again, advantage us. Almost all of them will be bigger, taller, and faster than USUs secondary. Croom is massive, North has incredible potential after only a freshman season, and Von Pearson is being toughted as a potential x factor for us with his freakish athleticism, Malone is unproven but already has shown signs of greatness after a standout spring game, and that's just scratching the surface. QB play could limit this though.
TEs: UT/USU
I'll call this a draw based on lack of knowledge of USUs TEs honestly. We have two big bodied, athletic freshman, one who can already make one handed catches, but I don't know enough about USUs.
QB: USU
USU all the way. Keeton is potential NFL material and a great QB. Short of an incredible turnaround in one of our QBs this is one of USUs strongest advantages.
O/D Line: USU
To keep this post short I'll condense this as I give the advantage here on both sides of the ball to USU. They have the experience advantage, we are the unknown. It could be even but it may not be. It's too early to tell.
LBs: USU
We have some great linebackers, but despite AJ Johnson, USU has 2 LBs that made the same watch list as him, and Maggitt is being considered to play mainly with his hand in the dirt it seems, but still may play LB. Slight advantage USU here.
Secondary: UT
I have to give this advantage to UT based on the lineups and overall skill. Brian Randolph and Cam Sutton are both poised to have breakout seasons and are on a watch list for best secondary player of the year. This will be one of our best defensive strengths in my opinion.
Martigan, or any USU/UT fan reading this, feel free to weigh in.
