Orange_Crush
Resident windbag genius
- Joined
- Dec 1, 2004
- Messages
- 37,987
- Likes
- 75,721
Oh FFS. The EC hasn’t fallen out of favor with the bodies that control how it is used the state legislatures. You spiking the ball on a idiot point about the popular vote splitting the EC based on a popular vote poll is stupid.You dodged defending your claim that the EC hasn’t fallen out of favor, but we both know you can’t defend it so we can move forward to something you can actually engage on without embarrassing yourself with some absurd justification.
Democracy is slow, but once the gerrymandered state legislatures have their feet held to the fire on this issue, especially if it starts to show up on party platforms, we very well may see that change. It might even happen in my lifetime.
The EC hasn't fallen out of favor in smaller states, and they're not going to just give up their voice. The only way to get rid of the EC is a Constitutional Amendment. Now, if you don't believe the FFs intended for each state to have a voice, ask yourself why the amendment process requires ratification by three-fourths of the states? This isn't a majority rule country.You dodged defending your claim that the EC hasn’t fallen out of favor, but we both know you can’t defend it so we can move forward to something you can actually engage on without embarrassing yourself with some absurd justification.
Democracy is slow, but once the gerrymandered state legislatures have their feet held to the fire on this issue, especially if it starts to show up on party platforms, we very well may see that change. It might even happen in my lifetime.
Oh, I'll jump. So what happened in the full video that we didn't see that justified a knee in the neck?
Just dropping the 2016 election results map by state as compared to the popular vote is all you need to show on why the majority of states won’t vote to do away with the ECI'm sure in the high population states that would benefit from a popular vote, the EC has fallen out of favor. It's not fallen out of favor in 38 out of 50 states, which is what would be required to get rid of it.
Yeah I’m sure that’s it.It’s only been two weeks.
Because VN and the court of public opinion is not the legal avenue through which this must travel. Because this is a tremendous amount of information requiring a tremendous amount of validating, swearing witnesses, before presenting the evidence into the legal system.
C’mon people...
I believe the average citizen is a civics dumbass and it’s pretty sad.
That point is valid. It’s a minority ruling over a majority, which is exactly why it’s not popular.
It’s not a “non starter”, it’s small states with disproportionate power obviously refusing to yield that disproportionate power.Oh FFS. The EC hasn’t fallen out of favor with the bodies that control how it is used the state legislatures. You spiking the ball on a idiot point about the popular vote splitting the EC based on a popular vote poll is stupid.
Democracy is indeed slow it appears after 250 years it’s decided it likes what it has.
The ONLY movement going on now is an end around to try and coerce state legislatures to redefine their EC count because everyone accepts a constitutional amendment to abolish the EC is a non starter. So they play outside the rules because they know they can’t win within the rules.
Yeah... Democracy is moving slower than a snails pace on your desires here LMFAO
Here I’ll show you this. And it actually supports what we’ve all been saying that the smaller states won’t agree to EC abolishment as opposed to your data not really supporting your claims.
View attachment 323300
much like "universial healthcare" or "gun control" OH believes that pie in the sky leftist BS will happen without the legal processes they have to go thru to get there....thus none of it will ever happenHere I’ll show you this. And it actually supports what we’ve all been saying that the smaller states won’t agree to EC abolishment as opposed to your data not really supporting your claims.
View attachment 323300
Yep. We are no where near the Borg mindset of the European countries which many opine to be like. We are a federalist government with mostly equal distributed powers between the central and regional (states) governments (well were supposed to be). And for our geography alone it makes sense. We are a huge nation. What works in NY doesn’t necessarily work in TXPeople don't understand the history of our country and how it was formed, let alone comprehend the Constitution and how and why it was written the way it was. They have an overview, and that's it. States were fiercely independent and they had to have a reason to come together in Union. It wasn't simply we banded together to overthrow British colonialism. When that was done, states had to have a reason to stay together. There had to be benefit to unity. Otherwise, they might as well have remained colonies.