In his first full season, Kimbrel has been the best closer in baseball, a flame-throwing automaton whose gaudy strikeout ratio and rookie-record 46 saves left hitters fearing him. At least until September. While Kimbrel’s raw stuff remained powerful – his fastball dancing near triple digits, his slider with more wipeout power than Windex – his command of it waned. The easy culprit was Fredi Gonzalez, the Braves’ first-year manager, whose usage patterns of Kimbrel prompted worry as early as May.
By the end of the month, Kimbrel had pitched in more than half of Atlanta’s games. At the All-Star break, he had thrown in 47 of 91, including 11 stints on back-to-back days and two more times pitching three consecutive days. Fans worried. Media, too. Gonzalez shrugged it off, even as the most respected man in his clubhouse said he was concerned with the overuse of Kimbrel and his two setup men, Jonny Venters(notes) and Eric O’Flaherty(notes).
“Yeah, I worried,” Chipper Jones said. “But when you get in a tight game, you worry about today today and deal with tomorrow tomorrow. Unfortunately, they were a part of today a lot and tomorrow a lot and the next day a lot.”
While other modern closers have matched Kimbrel’s workload, none have been rookies, let alone one shoehorned into a playoff race. After going 38 consecutive appearances without giving up a run – and with striking out 67 in 37 2/3 innings – Kimbrel blew a save Sept. 9. Then came another Sept. 19, and Wednesday night’s. Venters’ struggles in September left Gonzalez at least considering the Braves’ stretch gag – 9-18 over the final month – and the relievers’ efficacy might be of his own doing.
“Maybe they are [tired], maybe they’re not,” Gonzalez said. “Again, for me, those are excuses. If we hold their appearances back down, maybe we’re a .500 club. Maybe we’re not in this situation.”