Best RB of all time?

I think it's close to being out of the realm of debate about this.

Nobody has ever looked like a man amongst children in football's highest level like Jim Brown has, and it ain't even close.

Brown played in an era of slow, small white guys. Put him in the league today and he'd be average
Posted via VolNation Mobile
 
You can't really measure a player of the '50's and '60's with a player of today. It's all about what he did vs. the competition of the day. And nobody was better vs. the best of his time than Jim Brown.
 
Brown played in an era of slow, small white guys. Put him in the league today and he'd be average
Posted via VolNation Mobile

C'mon man, while it's true that Brown wouldn't have the "man among boys" physical advantage in today's game vs the 50's & 60's to think that his size, speed & strength wouldn't still make him one of the best RB's even now is simply silly.
 
If you're talking about the best season ever, or two season stretch, or the best dual threat backs of all time, then LT makes the list.

Faulk is a great player, possibly hall of fame, but not in the GOAT discussion.

I believe he is a lock on the first ballot
 
looked around and couldn't find a thread for this. A discussion was sparked in the barry sanders jr. thread in the recruiting forum about the best running back of all time. who do you think it is? i say barry sanders. base answers mostly off their NFL career.

Greatest in terms of accomplishments hands down is Emmitt Smith.

Greatest in terms of talent relative to their era, hands down Jim Brown.
 
Best I ever saw was Walter...film I have seen on Jim Brown is insane...he was a beast but quit at an early age...best all around, Payton. I base it on his talent, power, burst and he played on some awful teams against 8 in the box for years
 
Barry Sanders

He wasn't a big guy and was quiet to the point of nearly being introverted. Didn't play RB until the 4th game of his Sr yr in HS but then ripped off 188ypg for the rest of the season and earned All State.

All State or not he didn't get much attention from the big names and ended up at OK St where he backed up AA Thurman Thomas for two years. He did lead the nation in KOR in '87. As a starter in '88 he averaged 7.6ypc and 200+ypg, including 4 games over 300 and benchmarked a slew of single season records while winning the Heisman.

Listing Sanders NFL stats would be silly so there's no point in belaboring the issue. The only thing worth pointing out is that he had all that success with a pretty lousy team and with every defense knowing "If you stop Sanders you stop the Lions". They all tried, and often succeeded, in stopping the Lions. But like beating Jordan and the Bulls you knew Sanders would almost always get his yards, you're just trying to beat the rest of the team.

The only gripe I could begin to raise is his style didn't lend itself to any individual play. In other words if you absolutely had to have 3yds on this particular play he wasn't necessarily your guy. Having said that I don't think there's ever been anybody that was a bigger threat to leave defenders grabbing air and ripping off a big run on any given play than Sanders. He was simply wondrous to watch. As another poster said, with all due respect to Emmitt Smith if Sanders had been behind that Cowboys line of that time period I believe any and all RB conversations would begin with "Other than Barry Sanders...".

Dickerson probably deserves more credit than he's usually given.

Heard Okie St coach Pat Jones talk about Sanders last year. One day in practice Jones was talking to Thurmond Thomas when Sanders took a pitch a sped by them. Thomas looks at Jones and says "he sure sounds fast doesn't he" lol.:)
 
Barry Sanders was an incredible talent, but he was so unpredictable it hurt his team at times. He never ran the play as drawn up. He made incredible runs and he was always looking for the HR, but there's a reason he has more negative runs than anybody in history, and it's not because of his O Line.
 
Barry Sanders was an incredible talent, but he was so unpredictable it hurt his team at times. He never ran the play as drawn up. He made incredible runs and he was always looking for the HR, but there's a reason he has more negative runs than anybody in history, and it's not because of his O Line.

pat yourself on the back
 
I've only been following football since about '91...the best I've seen is Barry Sanders....although Marshall Faulk is up there along with LaDainian Tomlinson and Curtis Martin
 
Jim Brown...Maybe the best PLAYER to ever put on the pads too...Absolute beast in all aspects of the game...
 
I'm stunned that there are people who don't even put Brown in their top three or even top five... He's probably the best football player to ever put on pads, and it might not even be close.
 
I'm stunned that there are people who don't even put Brown in their top three or even top five... He's probably the best football player to ever put on pads, and it might not even be close.

I'm even more amazed by the people listing Barry Sanders. Did the guy even win a playoff game? Choke artist, I'd say Kevin Faulk had a better career.
 
Last edited:

VN Store



Back
Top