Guys that made our peak happen? What about Chuckie Keeton, Zach Vigil, Kyler Fackrell to name a few?
Name a few? That's pretty much it... isn't it?
I'm not even taking a shot at you... just stating some facts about where you sit. Maybe it goes up... maybe it stays roughly the same... maybe it goes down.
Historically speaking... down is the most likely direction.
I would guess that our program will continue to strike gold with underrated players. We call it player development. Whereas UT gets guys that are physically ready from Day 1, we have to prepare ours a bit and we do a fine job of it.
Jones places a high emphasis on player development as well. The problem with what you say is that you have to find that 180 lb kid who can grow into a 220 lb LB. There aren't that many of them and coaches great at seeing their potential... just aren't a dime a dozen.
So now the ones that were "hits" found by Petersen are mostly gone. Maybe there will be more or maybe not.
I could say the same thing to you, only the opposite. Maybe you program continues to fail with 5-star talent, but that would be atypical.
UT has had some decent talent come through even during the down period. It has not been developed very well. It hasn't been coached very well. Jones on the contrary seems to be very, very good at focused development of players. My remaining question about Jones is can he get it done on gameday. The guy can recruit and develop players.
UT's "failure" has come primarily in a conference where EVERYONE has 4-5* talent. It matters very little to the game on 8/31 but your best teams over the past 3 years would have struggled to even do as well as UT has done vs the same schedule.
To put it in perspective, according to ESPN you have played 3 teams in the past 3 years that finished ranked in the top 25 BCS poll. UT has played 4 of the last 6 BCS championship game contenders. They avg playing close to twice the number of ranked teams each season than you have played in 3 years.
Failure/success at UT vs USU... is a totally different enterprise.