Even though I'm a Manning fan ,Peyton has the best overall stats at present. I may have to give the nod, however so slightly to Drew. He did beat Peyton in the Super Bowl, which could have gone either way. We'll see what happens this year. Remember Peyton is coming off surgery and we'll see how well he comes off after the surgery. I do wish him the best and think he'll retire in 2-3 years. I think the Colts will draft a QB next season and hope to get a decent one. It's hard to get a good QB in the draft in the 2nd -3rd rounds. It's been done in the past though. Miami for one with Marino.