Once again...Oregon looks great because they play an incredibly weak schedule. The PAC does not recruit well compared to the SEC. In fact, Oregon out recruits all teams on their schedule (except for USC) and vastly out recruits everyone else but Stanford.
Look at the numbers for 2012. Oregon's recruiting average was a 17.5. Here are their opponents and their four year trailing talent average.
- Arkansas State (89.5)
- Fresno State (84.75)
- Arizona (54.75)
- Washington State (77.25)
- Airzona State (40)
- Colorado (56)
- USC (4.25)***
- California (23.25)
- Stanford (18.25)
- Oregon State (48)
- Kansas State (69.75)
This means that on average, Oregon had a 33 point difference between their talent and their opponent. Importantly, Oregon only played 1 school with a higher four year talent evaluation (USC).
Yes, the average margin of victory for Oregon was 25 points, but look at their opponents recruiting averages.
Yes, they beat USC who out recruited Oregon, but Kiff is notorious for under performance on a Dooley-esque level.
Stanford actually has less talent than Oregon (barely) and won (Stanford and SCAR are similar talent wise).
Here is a schedule comparison for last year:
Tennessee had a 12.25 four year trailing average. Our average opponent had a four year trailing average of about 30.4 (roughly 20 points higher than Oregon's competition). We played three teams who out recruited both us and the Ducks. Oregon played 4 teams who had talent averages BELOW the worst team on our schedule, that includes their bowl game.
- NCSU (56.25)
- Florida (7)
- Georgia (9.5)
- MSU (34.25)
- Bama (2)
- SCAR (18.25)
- Missouri (35)
- Vanderbilt (57.75)
- Kentucky (53.5)
The ducks are not world beaters, as typically shown by their performance when they play teams who are on par with them talent wise. All of this talk about "team speed" is so subjective as people are basing their perception on speed versus the opponent. Doesn't that require a look at the relative talent of Oregon's opponents?
Does Oregon win this game vs. UT? I would say the probability is high, due to any home field advantage and their confidence. Understand, however, that this game isn't a guaranteed blow out with UT having no chance. In fact, the way I view things this game is less of an upset than if UT beats UGA, Bama or Florida.
The key for UT will be how well our players mesh in a new system, and how well Jones can prepare them for this game coupled with the potential drop off from Oregon's change of coaching.
** I do not count any school that is not Division 1 in this analysis.