That's because Edge had a ton more carries in 2005 than Addai had in 2006. Addai was splitting time because he was a rookie and still had to learn how to pick up the blitz. You have to be blind or in total denial to not be able to see that Addai is a better runner than Edgerrin James and in even bigger denial to not see that the Colts, who are in the Super Bowl in 2006, are better off without James with whom they never made it to the Super Bowl. Come back next year. Addai will smoke 1,506 yards rushing next year. What a ridiculous argument.