'17 GA DT Aubrey Solomon (NCAA IS A FAIR ORGANIZATION)

Nobody really knows because it is all private unless the player or his family makes it public. Convenient for them.
Thing with Martell is that his lawyer basically did make it public. "Personality clashes" and coaching turnover (see link below). In the past, claiming those things as hardships would cause the NCAA to laugh at you and reject your waiver, but clearly things are changing, at least for once highly-touted recruits at premier positions.

Tate Martell's lawyer gives insight into why the QB transferred
 
  • Like
Reactions: SweetasSoda
Thing with Martell is that his lawyer basically did make it public. "Personality clashes" and coaching turnover (see link below). In the past, claiming those things as hardships would cause the NCAA to laugh at you and reject your waiver, but clearly things are changing, at least for once highly-touted recruits at premier positions.

Tate Martell's lawyer gives insight into why the QB transferred
Ohio state probably supported him in the waiver and didn't add or change anything.
 
  • Like
Reactions: SweetasSoda
But whatever the "narrative" is, there has to be some kind of hardship involved, right? Say a kid goes to a school and after a couple of years it becomes obvious he isn't going to crack the depth chart. If the kid makes an appeal to play immediately, and the school backs it, you're saying that consistency is all it takes to get it approved?

I thought there had to be some kind of extenuating hardship circumstance (i.e., not "the coach left" or "I'm not starting" or "another player just transferred in and is going to take my job") to get the NCAA to approve these waivers to play immediately.

Unless there's something we don't know (which is certainly possible), Martell didn't appear to have a strong case at all for immediate eligibility. In fact, he appeared to have no case whatsoever, at least based on how the NCAA has treated incidents like that in the past. Yet he got it and got it rather quickly, as have numerous other guys, yet there are other guys like Solomon that still haven't heard anything 5 days before the season starts. It makes no sense. I don't think he did a waiver, but why couldn't Jacob Eason, for example, get immediate eligibility when Jake Fromm took his job? I don't even remember that being discussed as a possibility at the time. I see that as no different as Martell leaving once Fields arrived, or Fields leaving because it was obvious he wasn't going to supplant Fromm.

Not necessarily a hardship. "Hardship" is one type, but not a term used with many cases.
 
Thing with Martell is that his lawyer basically did make it public. "Personality clashes" and coaching turnover (see link below). In the past, claiming those things as hardships would cause the NCAA to laugh at you and reject your waiver, but clearly things are changing, at least for once highly-touted recruits at premier positions.

Tate Martell's lawyer gives insight into why the QB transferred
They were being really lenient, but just passed some new guidelines so who knows now. Martell must have given his lawyer the right to do that. Personality clash could be used for anyone about anything like irreconcilable differences in a divorce. Like Sleegro said it must have been because OSU didn't oppose it.
 
  • Like
Reactions: Sleegro

VN Store



Back
Top