Oh okay. I’m bashing the kid bc I’m speaking the truth.
Yeah. You are using the fact that certain programs were interesting to him to act like he isn't any good. Just own it. Your biased view of the "truth" isn't... "the truth".
How he came to that point I have not heard. He did say however that he is excited to attend UT because it gives him the opportunity to get an engineering degree. So in regard to Vandy maybe he was attracted to the academics? Maybe he liked Arkansas because he likes hills? Who really knows. Arkansas isn't having a terrible recruiting year either. Five of their current 12 commits are 4*.
But reasoning it out really isn't you, huh? Looking at possibilities that do not conclude with the kid being sub-par have no appeal to you, right?
How many of these other elite players have Vandy and Arkansas in their top three?
Ridiculous question since neither of us have intimate knowledge of the feelings and preferences of the 400+ "elite players" per the recruiting sites.
Maybe... just maybe... he fell in love with UT and declined other opportunities? Is it not possible that the other programs who offered would have wanted to get an OV? Would we know if he declined unless he decided to say something?
Fwiw I’m fine with the commitment I just think it’s early given the other talent we’re in on at the position.
And that's probably the big difference between you and me and maybe others.
From what I understand at most programs they have "boards" but players are looked at in groups or buckets. So if you have 5 players in your top bucket and one of them wants to commit you take them even if #1 is still a possibility. You view those players in that grouping with equal or extremely similar value and potential.
That may not and usually does not align completely with the recruiting sites which you are probably hung up on. So the short answer there is that if they thought there were players available that were tons better than this kid and realistic possibilities... they wouldn't have taken his commitment.
I took another poster to task for claiming to have watched "film" on a recruit. We have access to highlight videos which obviously show a player's best plays and not the ones where he gets knocked on his can, fumbles, drops a pass, runs a rainbow route, throws a pick, etc.
However his video looks a lot like the ones from the LBs they took in the last class. He plays fast and is violent.
You just had a kneejerk negative reaction to this kid.