Jordan Matthews is a perfect example of how rating recruits out of high school isn't very cut and dry. He was a 2 star and will leave Vandy as the SEC all time leader in receptions an receiving yards! Coaching makes players better and wins u games. Many 4 and 5 star guys have been busts! Tennessee has had more talent than a lot of teams they've played the last few years and still lost to them. Kentucky in 11 , Vandy and MSU in 12 come to mine.
Again, and I don't know how else to explain this, what you are citing are exceptions to a well defined rule. There are always exceptions. I will take the rule that works 80% of the time, over the exception, any day.
.