RDU VOL#14
I’m a Flawed Character
- Joined
- Sep 11, 2007
- Messages
- 26,447
- Likes
- 39,331
If it takes him 7 years to develop an elite skill, then I doubt it happens. I just think players reach that level much younger now than 10-15 years ago. I think he's more of good to great at several facets but elite at none. I think he's going to be a very valuable player and a winner...I just don't think he's "generational".He just barely turned 18. You're not supposed to be elite skill-wise for another 7 years, after you've played in 300+ NBA games and had a couple good playoff runs.
If it takes him 7 years to develop an elite skill, then I doubt it happens. I just think players reach that level much younger now than 10-15 years ago. I think he's more of good to great at several facets but elite at none. I think he's going to be a very valuable player and a winner...I just don't think he's "generational".
He's definitely one of the best college players of the one-and-done era. I don't know if he's better than Carmelo Anthony or Kevin Durant, but he's up there.
He certainly did have a Cam Newton-type impact on his team and the sport the year he played. Auburn wasn't expected to do all that much that year either and was probably a 7 or 8 win team (maybe worse) without him.The thing about Melo and why he is the best one and done to me is that Syracuse was not expected to do much all season and then they ran in and knocked off Texas in the tourney and then won the title.
Durant / Texas were basically a top 15 team all season start to finish.
Flagg / Duke were top 5-8 all year this year.
Syracuse and Melo didn't enter the top 25 until 2 weeks into January 2003
The thing about Melo and why he is the best one and done to me is that Syracuse was not expected to do much all season and then they ran in and knocked off Texas in the tourney and then won the title.
Durant / Texas were basically a top 15 team all season start to finish.
Flagg / Duke were top 5-8 all year this year.
Syracuse and Melo didn't enter the top 25 until 2 weeks into January 2003
Syracuse was mediocre the year before but they brought in McNamara the same class as Melo who was a big part of that core for years. They also had Hakim Warrick already on campus. I’d imagine they would have been an at-large teamHe certainly did have a Cam Newton-type impact on his team and the sport the year he played. Auburn wasn't expected to do all that much that year either and was probably a 7 or 8 win team (maybe worse) without him.
I don't remember as much about that 2003 Cuse team - they might not have been a mediocre team without Melo, but they certainly don't win or even sniff a title without him.
YOMV?He is IMO as good if not better , even at 18 years old, as any college player Ive ever seen. Ive watched a lot of basketball . Played a lot of basketball. Saw Jerry West and Kareen in Final Fours in person. Larry Bird. Magic Johnson. Saw Michael Jordan in person in ACC games; Flagg in the current game as played is a phenomenal talent and dominator. I hate Duke. Seriously hate Duke. But this guy is really something IMO. YOMV
C'mon, Larry Bird took a bunch of plumbers at Indiana State to an undefeated season and the Championship game vs Magic and MI State which they lost by less than 10 points. Bird had a coach who was barely over .500 wins in his career. He had nothing.He is IMO as good if not better , even at 18 years old, as any college player Ive ever seen. Ive watched a lot of basketball . Played a lot of basketball. Saw Jerry West and Kareen in Final Fours in person. Larry Bird. Magic Johnson. Saw Michael Jordan in person in ACC games; Flagg in the current game as played is a phenomenal talent and dominator. I hate Duke. Seriously hate Duke. But this guy is really something IMO. YOMV