He got Teddy Bridgewater to go to Louisville over offers from several big time programs.
Take a look at their roster:
Lot's of Florida kids
Obviously, their classes aren't great, but I'd say he recruited Miami kids pretty well for a school with very little facilities or football tradition.
As for the Cincy and Lville comparison, I'm not sure what observation you made.
Charlie Strong has out-recruited Butch Jones 2 out of 3 years, but if you look closer, you see that he has added 8 4* players in the last 3 years, while Butch Jones has signed just 2. The only reason Cincy's 2012 class is ranked higher than Louisville's is because Cincy signed 30 players to Lville's 22. Prior to Strong and Jones, Brian Kelly(cincy) out recruited Steve Kragthorpe(Lville) 2 out of 3 years, but again Lville signed more 4*'s. Prior to Kelly's hiring in 2006, Cincinatti's recruiting was a dumpster fire(70's-80's). Meanwhile, Louisville coach, wait for it, Bobby Petrino consistently had classes in the 40 - 50 range with the exception of the 2006 class which was Petrino's last year at Lville.
So basically, Louisville has usually had classes in 40 - 50 range prior to Strong, and now has classes in 30 - 40 range with Strong. Cincy recruiting improved a ton when Brian Kelly was hired.
(Higher ranked class in
bold:
2012:
Cincy #34 (signed 30, 0 4*); Lville #42 (signed 22, 3 4*)
2011: Cincy #42 (signed 25, 1 4*);
Lville #33 (signed 21, 3 4*)
2010: Cincy #61 (signed 23, 1 4*);
Lville #44 (signed 27, 2 4*)
*** Charlie Strong hired December, 2009 2 months before signing day 2010 ***
*** Butch Jones hired December, 2009 2 months before signing day 2010 ***
2009:
Cincy #53 (signed 24, 2 4*); Lville #64 (signed 25, 1 4*)
2008:
Cincy #51 (signed 24, 0 4*); Lville #54 (signed 22, 1 4*)
2007: Cincy #80 (signed 23, 0 4*);
Lville #47 (signed 16, 6 4*)
*** Steve Kragthorpe hired by Louisville Jan 2009 just before signing day ***
*** Brian Kelly hired by Cincinatti December 2006 2 months before signing day ***
2006: Cincy #70 (signed 18, 1 4*);
Lville #26 (signed 29, 1 5*, 4 4*)
2005: Cincy #70 (signed 24, 0 4*);
Lville #43 (signed 27, 5 4*)
2004: Cincy #75 (signed 21, 0 4*);
Lville #54 (signed 24, 1 4*)
2003: Cincy #84 (signed 24, 0 4*);
Lville #48 (signed 31, 1 4*)
*** Bobby Petrino Lville head coach 2003 - 2006 ***
tl;dr: Prior to Brian Kelly (Lville recruiting >>>>>>>>>> Cincy recruiting).
After Brian Kelly (Lville recruiting == Cincy recruiting)
All stats from
Scout Recruiting Rankings