Try again brother. You're making like Stretch Armstrong on this one. Silly analogy.
No sir---I'm exposing the silliness of your thinking and your statements when you STRETCH the YPC stats of both Kamara and Kelly in order to ASSUME that those guys would've maintained the same YPC numbers against the opponents we played early in the year..... That is what is SILLY....
You assume that the conditions all of these RBs faced were identical because of our OL....but that is where your comparison breaks down...because Kamara and Kelly generated their YPC against those "juggernaut" run defenses like aTm, TTU, Mizzou, KY, and Vandy...
I wonder what kind of numbers a healthy Hurd would've put up against those teams??? We DON'T know---any more than you can conclude that Kamara and Kelly would've maintained their YPC average against the teams we played earlier in the season.
It's pointless to even attempt to continue a logical discussion with you and others on here because of the animosity and bias against Hurd because he quit...
But I will point out that we've heard all of these arguments before in Volnation in the comparisons that were made between Foster, Coker, Creer, and Hardesty.
The conclusions you have posted about Hurd in this thread are almost a carbon copy of the ignorant statements made by Vol fans long ago about Foster.
And how did that turn out?
Some people just never learn.....