kcvols1
Well-Known Member
- Joined
- Sep 13, 2006
- Messages
- 5,566
- Likes
- 4,070
My stance actually does make sense if you’re capable of critical thinking.
Also, I never said he sucked - just with clearly outlined reasoning questioned this commitment.
Read slower so maybe you can keep up.
We know recruiting services are struggling to rank kids this year......how do we know they are listing all the teams that are reaching out to this kid?If I’m starving, I’ll eat Ramen. But I’m not gonna be excited about eating Ramen. That’s my point.
Not a single person on this forum is qualified to intelligently determine if this kid can play. The two generally accepted metrics we use are offers and rankings. Rankings are sketchy for many reasons in normal years - but especially this year.
I’m not so much concerned with his lack of a ranking. What is alarming is his playing a premium position at a top flight JUCO with high visibility - and the lack of offers. Every team needs corners. UGA is loaded on defense and they still offered and accepted kids from the portal.
Can Martinez get something out of him? Sure it’s possible. Could Martinez get something more out of a ‘22 kid that this commitment takes a number from? Very likely.
Being skeptical about this doesn’t make someone a “negavol.” When guys like Means and Brandon Davis etc were signed everyone pointed to DeAndre Baker and how we had no right to question Pruitt. Well, there is a very strong likelihood that this player contributes as much as those two.
We know recruiting services are struggling to rank kids this year......how do we know they are listing all the teams that are reaching out to this kid?
There's nothing wrong with being concerned or not being excited. But if no one is qualified to evaluate, and there are always going to be players that don't work out in every class, we just have to say "welcome to Rocky Top " and go on. Only other choice we have is start running down the players that are choosing to play for Tennessee. I think the coaches are getting the best they can right now to fill the holes we have.If I’m starving, I’ll eat Ramen. But I’m not gonna be excited about eating Ramen. That’s my point.
Not a single person on this forum is qualified to intelligently determine if this kid can play. The two generally accepted metrics we use are offers and rankings. Rankings are sketchy for many reasons in normal years - but especially this year.
I’m not so much concerned with his lack of a ranking. What is alarming is his playing a premium position at a top flight JUCO with high visibility - and the lack of offers. Every team needs corners. UGA is loaded on defense and they still offered and accepted kids from the portal.
Can Martinez get something out of him? Sure it’s possible. Could Martinez get something more out of a ‘22 kid that this commitment takes a number from? Very likely.
Being skeptical about this doesn’t make someone a “negavol.” When guys like Means and Brandon Davis etc were signed everyone pointed to DeAndre Baker and how we had no right to question Pruitt. Well, there is a very strong likelihood that this player contributes as much as those two.