Im simply pointing out a mathematical fact; that in power 5 coaching, Butchs win total and Kiffins are very similar, or at least they were until about a month ago.
At his dream job he had a roster full of NFL caliber talent and only produced one 10 win season in a pretty weak power 5 conference in the PAC12. A lot of people bring up the scholarship reductions he was forced to deal with, but those didnt take effect until year 3, meaning the entire time he was there he had a full class of juniors and seniors. He had everything he needed to win there, including Neuheisel as his cross town rival, and couldnt make it happen. He is unproven at best as a head coach in power 5 and not worthy of a second chance here.
Your best defense of him is what hes done this year at FAU, which is impressive, but not nearly enough when judged against the rest of his resume. And if all of that werent enough, hes an unlikable, trolling, twitter addict whos best skill is self promotion. Do. Not. Want.