volinbham
VN GURU
- Joined
- Oct 21, 2004
- Messages
- 69,595
- Likes
- 61,659
How was their response disastrous?
from the article:
The details of Swedish policies as described by Brusselaers and her co-authors are horrifying. The Swedish government, they report, deliberately tried to use children to spread COVID-19 and denied care to seniors and those suffering from other conditions.
clearly bad policy but this is bad journalism
That’s a reproach to the signers of the Great Barrington Declaration, a widely criticized white paper endorsing the quest for herd immunity and co-written by Martin Kulldorff, a Sweden-born Harvard professor who has explicitly defended his native country’s policies.
The GBD never recommended what Sweden did to the elderly (the opposite in fact) nor did it recommend using kids to deliberately spread it. The "widely criticized white paper" phrase is a give away of the author's leanings. It was also widely praised and in hindsight appears to be a better strategy what the US implemented.
More poor journalism
The bottom line is that Swedes suffered grievously from Tegnell’s policies. According to the authoritative Johns Hopkins pandemic tracker, while its total death rate from February 2020 through this week, 1,790 per million population, is better than that of the U.S. (2,939), Britain (2,420) and France (2,107), it’s worse than that of Germany (1,539), Canada (984) and Japan (220).
If the Swedes suffered grievously from Tegnell's policies then it stands to reason American, Brits and Francos suffered even more grievously.