'20 NC QB Navy Shuler

#456
#456
Ace said:
I have a feeling he will never see the field. I am sure he is a good kid, but he showed nothing at App State.
If his name was not Shuler, he would not be on this roster
Click to expand...
I don't know how good he is or isn't. The family feels like he's very good. He's just small.

However he was just a Fr at ASU playing behind a multi-year starter. Not sure what you expected him to do.
 
  • Like
Reactions: SoilVol, Wolfeman_Vol, walkenvol and 3 others
#459
#459
peaygolf said:
I've got a funny feeling this kid is going to be thrust into action at some point..............and play really well when he does.
Click to expand...
Hope no time soon lol no offense to the kid but I really want hooker to pass the reigns to tayven I wouldn’t be mad with one more attempt at Joe Milton after 3 years of CJH molding him but if we get to navy would mean we missed on some higher guys…
 
#460
#460
Ace said:
I hope he does well, but I know he did not show much at App State.
Click to expand...
In what respect and with what opportunities? Are you close enough to the program to have observed practices? How can he show anything good or bad if he didn't play or as best I can find ever attempt a pass?

I do not wish bad for him.
Click to expand...
Didn't assume you did. I'm just wondering what you have to base any opinion on? Not sure how old you are but Baker Mayfield started as a Fr Walk-on at TTU. The opportunity fell in his lap. Not common... a Cinderella story to be sure that a short, small QB would walk on and become a success in both CFB and NFL. I don't know Navy. If I've ever seen him it was when he was a baby... maybe. But I know the family and am FB friends with several. They were excited and believe he's a talented guy. Families are biased of course... but they know him and have seen him play.

We have other QBs with much more upside and I think we will would be in trouble if we were depending on him.
Click to expand...
From where we sit today, it looks like Tayven has more "upside". But wouldn't that all be better judged after it happens? If JG didn't teach us anything... it is that the true test of a QB is when the bullets start flying.

He has an NIL because he is a Shuler, not because of his potential to be the QB at UT.
Click to expand...
Really? I had not read that. Do you have a source? Wonder why West Shuler didn't get special treatment. He's family.

The company paying him has every right to do so.
Click to expand...
Agree. And my problem with what you're posting isn't anything I have vested in Navy Shuler... just that you're making definitive statements without saying how you "know" them to be true.
 
  • Like
Reactions: SoilVol and walkenvol
#461
#461
BoroVol93 said:
Hope no time soon lol no offense to the kid but I really want hooker to pass the reigns to tayven I wouldn’t be mad with one more attempt at Joe Milton after 3 years of CJH molding him but if we get to navy would mean we missed on some higher guys…
Click to expand...
Much too early... but I won't be shocked if UT recruits over both of them in the next class.
 
  • Like
Reactions: VOLINVONORE
#466
#466
sjt18 said:
In what respect and with what opportunities? Are you close enough to the program to have observed practices? How can he show anything good or bad if he didn't play or as best I can find ever attempt a pass?

Didn't assume you did. I'm just wondering what you have to base any opinion on? Not sure how old you are but Baker Mayfield started as a Fr Walk-on at TTU. The opportunity fell in his lap. Not common... a Cinderella story to be sure that a short, small QB would walk on and become a success in both CFB and NFL. I don't know Navy. If I've ever seen him it was when he was a baby... maybe. But I know the family and am FB friends with several. They were excited and believe he's a talented guy. Families are biased of course... but they know him and have seen him play.

From where we sit today, it looks like Tayven has more "upside". But wouldn't that all be better judged after it happens? If JG didn't teach us anything... it is that the true test of a QB is when the bullets start flying.

Really? I had not read that. Do you have a source? Wonder why West Shuler didn't get special treatment. He's family.


Agree. And my problem with what you're posting isn't anything I have vested in Navy Shuler... just that you're making definitive statements without saying how you "know" them to be true.
Click to expand...
You have valid points and I should have refrained from posting on Navy. I will erase my post and I respect you for admonishing me. I do hope he does well. Thank you for helping me see that I need to take a break from VN.
 
#467
#467
Ace said:
You have valid points and I should have refrained from posting on Navy. I will erase my post and I respect you for admonishing me. I do hope he does well. Thank you for helping me see that I need to take a break from VN.
Click to expand...
Yeah. That's what you should take from that exchange... good grief. If you have reasons for believing something then say so. If it is an unqualified opinion then don't act like that's "just the way it will be".
 
#469
#469
Bassmaster_Vol said:
but we’re not doing anything with NIL
Click to expand...
Nobody thinks we're doing nothing with nil. People just don't believe we're dropping hundreds of thousands of dollars. Not sure why that's such an absurd thought. Also not not sure why y'all get so butthurt when someone has a different opinion on the matter. There's zero proof anywhere we're spending six figures on anyone.
 
#470
#470
Rylee_Vol18 said:
Nobody thinks we're doing nothing with nil. People just don't believe we're dropping hundreds of thousands of dollars. Not sure why that's such an absurd thought. Also not not sure why y'all get so butthurt when someone has a different opinion on the matter. There's zero proof anywhere we're spending six figures on anyone.
Click to expand...
Zero proof. Except Volquest and Swain telling us we are. But those guys don’t know anything. They’re just lying and making it up
 
  • Like
Reactions: SoilVol, SugarCC, Bruce Wayne and 3 others
#471
#471
Bassmaster_Vol said:
Zero proof. Except Volquest and Swain telling us we are. But those guys don’t know anything. They’re just lying and making it up
Click to expand...
I'd love to be proven wrong because I think he deserves it but Tennessee is always cheap in everything they do.
 
New posts
You must log in or register to reply here.

VN Store



Back
Top