ntxVOL
Well-Known Member
- Joined
- Sep 29, 2011
- Messages
- 1,605
- Likes
- 1,840
Disorderly conduct which can be the equivalent of annoying a cop just by walking by is a misdemeanor so is reckless driving (speeding with 10-15 mph over the limit) or Public Intoxication. Breaking someone's face isn't on the same level as those types of crimes which is what most normal people mean when they say 'it's just a misdemeanor'. Even a bar fight between two guys where the worst one does is split someone's lip or give them a shiner isn't on the same level as breaking their face or beating them to a bloody pulp even though those could all result in the same exact charge.
Even felonies are like this. Theft over a certain amount (which can be something as 'petty' as stealing someone's phone) can add up to a felony because that's often based on a dollar amount and in some states it can be an incredibly small amount. Possession laws are just as messed up. And yet those crimes do not equal breaking someone's face let alone breaking someone's face when you're substantially more powerful/stronger than the person you're hitting.
Call me crazy but I'd much rather have someone snatch my phone from a table while I'm at a bar than break my face regardless of whether the phone adds up to a felony but breaking my face is only a misdemeanor.
FWIW, DA said that she was drunk, started the confrontation and slapped him. He responded by punching her. That's why he was only charged with a misdemeanor.