Proof the CFP is about the "best" teams not the "most deserving"

[RDU VOL#14]

if this was a CFP game with Rodemaker at QB it would be competitive. Stop with the fake news narrative please and thank you.

FSU was robbed. Winning games doesn’t matter. Period end of story.

Define competitive.

 

[UTFranklinVol]

So what about the the multiple 1 and 2 and 3 loss teams who have looked better than WASH and TX down the stretch ? Why not take a 3 loss team like LSU who would boat race wash ?

Oh it’s because winning matters when you want it to, but if it doesn’t fit the narrative then it doesn’t really matter that much. Got it.

No, winning matters when you're in the SEC and have to face those teams every year. I've said it since 2007 that a 2 loss SEC team is better than any other football team in any other conference. I was right back then and still right today and always.

Wins matter only in the right circumstances. That's what happens when there's over 100 football teams. Deal with it.

 

[Carlitovol]

And MICH deserves to be in over FSU because of their amazing schedule am I right ? Because MICH’s schedule was so much stronger than FSU’s right ? Hahaha

And MICH didn’t just squeak in. They are the NUMBER 1 team in all of college football after playing an easier schedule than FSU.

Oh because they’re undefeated ? So winning matters until it doesn’t.

Wait so the #1 seed played a hot garbage big 10 schedule and nobody bats an eye. Haha.

But FSU is clearly this terrible team that doesn’t deserve to sniff the top 4. Got it.

(Because of their supposedly atrocious schedule. Got it)

 

[Carlitovol]

No, winning matters when you're in the SEC and have to face those teams every year. I've said it since 2007 that a 2 loss SEC team is better than any other football team in any other conference. I was right back then and still right today and always.

Wins matter only in the right circumstances. That's what happens when there's over 100 football teams. Deal with it.

Holy crap you like to talk in circles. What do you say about my MICH post ? Please enlighten me.

 

[Carlitovol]

Holy crap you like to talk in circles. What do you say about my MICH post ? Please enlighten me.

No, winning matters when you're in the SEC and have to face those teams every year. I've said it since 2007 that a 2 loss SEC team is better than any other football team in any other conference. I was right back then and still right today and always.

Wins matter only in the right circumstances. That's what happens when there's over 100 football teams. Deal with it.

So why doesn’t the CFP just take the top 4 SEC teams. That would be a helluva lot easier

 

[GUNTERSVOL]

So winning games doesn’t matter I guess ? TX got beat by a piss poor OK team who got curb stomped by farking AZ in their bowl game. So who deserved to be in the CFP ???

How many of the missing pieces for FSU would have shown up if they got in the CFP? Can't respect an argument for a team when that many team members put other priorities over being in a big bowl game with their teammates and repping the school.

 

[Carlitovol]

How many of the missing pieces for FSU would have shown up if they got in the CFP? Can't respect an argument for a team when that many team members put other priorities over being in a big bowl game with their teammates and repping the school.

That is a straw man argument if I’ve ever heard one and has zero bearing on the discussion. If any of the CFP teams had gotten left out there is a 99% chance that there would be all kinds of opt outs.

 

[UTFranklinVol]

And MICH deserves to be in over FSU because of their amazing schedule am I right ? Because MICH’s schedule was so much stronger than FSU’s right ? Hahaha

And MICH didn’t just squeak in. They are the NUMBER 1 team in all of college football after playing an easier schedule than FSU.

Oh because they’re undefeated ? So winning matters until it doesn’t.

Wait so the #1 seed played a hot garbage big 10 schedule and nobody bats an eye. Haha.

But FSU is clearly this terrible team that doesn’t deserve to sniff the top 4. Got it.

You serious Clark? You lost me at Michigan being a worse team. You clearly don't watch football and the CFP agrees. Michigan beat 2 top 10 teams. FSU beat #13 LSU and #16 Louisville.

The class of the ACC is Clemson and they sucked this year. Thats all the ACC had for competition and FSU won the league by default as the least sucky team.

FSU tried to ride the "cache" of being an undefeated P5 team when in reality there's only a P2 and nothing else out there.

 

[loservol]

You do realize FSU has one starter playing on defense tonight right? And defense was their bread and butter. And the original starting qb transferred so they are playing with a third stringer. I loathe FSU but thinking they didn’t deserve to be in the playoff is a terrible take. Money and popularity have become the focus and Division one football will continue to become more and more corrupt.

Even at full strength, dumb dawgs would have still beat the living daylights out of FSU.

 

[UTFranklinVol]

So why doesn’t the CFP just take the top 4 SEC teams. That would be a helluva lot easier

I agree completely. But it's "not fair"

 

[UTFranklinVol]

Or what about a MICH team who played literally no one except an overrated OSU team?

Because they’re undefeated ? Oh yeah, winning matters right ? Or does it, I forget ??

Michigan beat 2 top10 teams and then shut out #20 Iowa so..... FSU didn't do that not even close.

 

[Carlitovol]

You serious Clark? You lost me at Michigan being a worse team. You clearly don't watch football and the CFP agrees. Michigan beat 2 top 10 teams. FSU beat #13 LSU and #16 Louisville.

The class of the ACC is Clemson and they sucked this year. Thats all the ACC had for competition and FSU won the league by default as the least sucky team.

FSU tried to ride the "cache" of being an undefeated P5 team when in reality there's only a P2 and nothing else out there.

2 top 10 teams OSU nearly lost multiple games amd PSU is the most overrated team in CFB. did you watch their game today Eddie ?!?

 

[loservol]

So why doesn’t the CFP just take the top 4 SEC teams. That would be a helluva lot easier

Next year the top 4 SEC teams will probably be in it.

 

[UTFranklinVol]

2 top 10 teams OSU nearly lost multiple games amd PSU is the most overrated team in CFB. did you watch their game today Eddie ?!?

Michigan would monkey stomp FSU. Go to bed Sally. It's past your bed time

 

[Carlitovol]

2 top 10 teams OSU nearly lost multiple games amd PSU is the most overrated team in CFB. did you watch their game today Eddie ?!?

Guess who mighty MICH beat in their mighty conf championship game ?

A team who:

Failed to score a SINGLE point. Did you catch that. Not even a FG.

And is about to get trucked by the VOLS.

But plz tell me about how great MICH is and I want to hear more about their incredible schedule.

I just checked and their OOC schedule was awesome. ECU, Bowling green and UNLV.

INCREDIBLE !!

 

[TrueOrange]

Still, losing by 70 is not acceptable. Why even show up? Just forfeit the game and admit you were not worthy.

(1) The school wouldn’t get its millions of dollars in payoff, (2) the Orange Bowl committee would - as someone else put it - “sue the living crap out of them” in a lawsuit that they would win against Florida State University easily (presuming the city of Miami wouldn’t also sue the school and likely win easily).

That would turn into a massive financial loss.

 

[Carlitovol]

And holy crap that MICH team beat mighty Maryland by 7. Dude !!

 

[UTFranklinVol]

Guess who mighty MICH beat in their mighty conf championship game ?

A team who:

Failed to score a SINGLE point. Did you catch that. Not even a FG.

And is about to get trucked by the VOLS.

But plz tell me about how great MICH is and I want to hear more about their incredible schedule.

I just checked and their OOC schedule was awesome. ECU, Bowling green and UNLV.

INCREDIBLE !!

Boy I hope you come back here if Iowa beats Tennessee. You just proved how low your IQ is. You're betting your good word on the terribly Vols lol. You've been huffing a little too much paint.

Michigan Bama Georgia and Texas or Washington. Those are the best teams in college football. Nothing will change my mind so all your words mean nothing to me because I already know I'm right. It's pointless to argue.

 

[Carlitovol]

Michigan would monkey stomp FSU. Go to bed Sally. It's past your bed time

In all honesty I would concede this debate if MICH had beaten 2 SEC teams. Or HELL even played a SINGLE P5 non-conference opponent. But guess what, they scared. But they’re still somehow the unanimous #1 team in all of football.

Crickets are chirping !!

 

[UTFranklinVol]

And holy crap that MICH team beat mighty Maryland by 7. Dude !!

FSU is trash dude, sober up and go to bed.

 

[Carlitovol]

FSU is trash dude, sober up and go to bed.

Fantastic argument. Got it.

 

[UTFranklinVol]

In all honesty I would concede this debate if MICH had beaten 2 SEC teams. Or HELL even played a SINGLE P5 non-conference opponent. But guess what, they scared. But they’re still somehow the unanimous #1 team in all of football.

Crickets are chirping !!

Dude saying FSU beat 2 SEC teams means nothing because they didn't beat Bama or Georgia. Beating crappy Florida means nothing!

Oh Florida beat Tennessee! Yeah thats right because Tennessee SUCKS. We lose game we have no business losing.

LSU is the 5th best team in the SEC.

Tell me who else FSU beat that matters compared to PSU or OSU? You can't! Just stop.

 

[Carlitovol]

FSU is trash dude, sober up and go to bed.

Still loving that Michigan OOC schedule. Aww inspiring for real.

 

[Carlitovol]

Dude saying FSU beat 2 SEC teams means nothing because they didn't beat Bama or Georgia. Beating crappy Florida means nothing!

Oh Florida beat Tennessee! Yeah thats right because Tennessee SUCKS. We lose game we have no business losing.

LSU is the 5th best team in the SEC.

Tell me who else FSU beat that matters compared to PSU or OSU? You can't! Just stop.

LSU beat Mizzou who just dominated OSU.

LSU gave a game away at Ole Miss who destroyed PSU today.

But they’re bad because the SEC sucks I guess? But if the SEC sucks then that means bama sucks too right ? Kinda like FSU and the ACC ?

 

[Carlitovol]

LSU beat Mizzou who just dominated OSU.

LSU gave a game away at Ole Miss who destroyed PSU today.

But they’re bad because the SEC sucks I guess? But if the SEC sucks then that means bama sucks too right ? Kinda like FSU and the ACC ?

The double standard is Real.