RDU VOL#14
I’m a Flawed Character
- Joined
- Sep 11, 2007
- Messages
- 25,302
- Likes
- 37,292
I'm not saying the mutilation doesn't appall me, but it pails in comparison to a loss of life.
So, back to Omar, who was expressing the more morally acceptable view? She, who was basically speaking out about a guy who was trying to elevate the loss of American combatants over somali civilians, or he, who was elevating the loss of American combatants over the loss of Somali civilians (19 vs 230)?
If my loved one was on a mission to feed your loved one and your loved one participated in the slaughter of my loved one then I would spit on your loved one and come looking for you.What's a bigger tragedy--when you lose a loved one or when I lose a loved one? From your perspective, you may view your loss as greater, from my perspective, I may view mine as greater. But from a neutral perspective, they should be viewed as the same.
The whole thing started when the one guy responded to Al Franken by saying the loss of 19 soldiers was a bigger loss than the loss of 230 civilians. I think a neutral observer would say the bigger loss/tragedy was the civilian loss of 230. The number is greater and they were civilians (i.e., non-combatants). Do you disagree with that?
No you’re not saying it. In fact you’re totally ignoring it, deflecting away from it, basically finding any way you can to prop up your terrorist girl. Non-combatants...I'm not saying the mutilation doesn't appall me, but it pails in comparison to a loss of life.
So, back to Omar, who was expressing the more morally acceptable view? She, who was basically speaking out about a guy who was trying to elevate the loss of American combatants over somali civilians, or he, who was elevating the loss of American combatants over the loss of Somali civilians (19 vs 230)?
No you’re not saying it. In fact you’re totally ignoring it, deflecting away from it, basically finding any way you can to prop up your terrorist girl. Non-combatants...
The terrorist attack that Al Franken tweeted about killed hundreds of civilians. Those are non-combatants. The battle of Mogadishu was between US soldiers (combatants) and armed militants/militiamen (combatants). That is not a terrorist attack. Eo ipso, it can't be the worst terrorist attack in the country's history. Additionally, hundreds of civilians were killed by US forces in the battle of Mogadishu, a fact selectively ignored by the guy when he said that the worst terrorist attack in Somalia's history left 19 US soldiers dead and 73 wounded. The only person being a dick here was the guy claiming, effectively, that the value of Somalis was substantially less than the value of Americans.
It's a matter of perspective. The lives of American soldiers are more valuable to me than the lives of Somali citizens. That is because I can identify with them and their families and friends. From their point of view, and yours apparently, the lives of Somali citizens have more value because you hate this country and the military.The terrorist attack that Al Franken tweeted about killed hundreds of civilians. Those are non-combatants. The battle of Mogadishu was between US soldiers (combatants) and armed militants/militiamen (combatants). That is not a terrorist attack. Eo ipso, it can't be the worst terrorist attack in the country's history. Additionally, hundreds of civilians were killed by US forces in the battle of Mogadishu, a fact selectively ignored by the guy when he said that the worst terrorist attack in Somalia's history left 19 US soldiers dead and 73 wounded. The only person being a dick here was the guy claiming, effectively, that the value of Somalis was substantially less than the value of Americans.
And you went thru this whole diatribe while again totally ignoring the desecration of our soldiers’ bodies which was the majority of my post. You cannot acknowledge that fact or you’d have to admit the terrorist from Minnesota is a POS that we should throw the hell back into Somalia.The terrorist attack that Al Franken tweeted about killed hundreds of civilians. Those are non-combatants. The battle of Mogadishu was between US soldiers (combatants) and armed militants/militiamen (combatants). That is not a terrorist attack. Eo ipso, it can't be the worst terrorist attack in the country's history. Additionally, hundreds of civilians were killed by US forces in the battle of Mogadishu, a fact selectively ignored by the guy when he said that the worst terrorist attack in Somalia's history left 19 US soldiers dead and 73 wounded. The only person being a dick here was the guy claiming, effectively, that the value of Somalis was substantially less than the value of Americans.
And you went thru this whole diatribe while again totally ignoring the desecration of our soldiers’ bodies which was the majority of my post. You cannot acknowledge that fact or you’d have to admit the terrorist from Minnesota is a POS that we should throw the hell back into Somalia.
And Hogg already called your BS lack of knowledge on the events in question.
And you went thru this whole diatribe while again totally ignoring the desecration of our soldiers’ bodies which was the majority of my post. You cannot acknowledge that fact or you’d have to admit the terrorist from Minnesota is a POS that we should throw the hell back into Somalia.
And Hogg already called your BS lack of knowledge on the events in question.
Still rationalizing abhorrent behavior. “Oh well he’s already dead let’s piss on him too!”. Disgusting.Desecration of a body is bad for the living, but if someone is dead already, I stand by my claim that killing someone is worse than desecrating the body of someone who's already dead. Do you believe differently? I doubt you do.
Still rationalizing abhorrent behavior. “Oh well he’s already dead let’s piss on him too!”. Disgusting.
Desecration happens on all sides now. Even elite US forces are accused of the same. Extreme and constant war does strange things to people. We should probably look for ways to end that first and other actions will follow on their ownLoss of life is a loss of life, regardless of the numbers. However, it's the manner in which the lives were lost as to the severity of it.
Furthermore, the desecration of the bodies of US Army personnel in the aftermath of Mogadishu should appall you.