You judge a program by its POTENTIAL. Since Neyland got here in 1926 the potential of this program has been the ability to win conference and national championships.
The only time we are not competing for championships is when we have had awful coaching. Neyland retired and we kept running an antiquated offense until Dickey got here (still had a couple great seasons in there like 1956 because WE ARE TENNESSEE) Dickey screwed us and Bill Battle let everything go to shambles. Johnny had to rebuild. He did. Fulmer won a title. We fired him and everything went back to crap.
What happens when we finally get another good coach? Ranked number one in year two. How? BECAUSE WE ARE TENNESSEE. Not a freaking "8-4" program.
I get you are just referencing data, but that's just an incomplete perspective, but since you want to go there.
Tennessee was 645-256 from 1926-2008 before the debacle that was the last 15 years.
You know who in the SEC had more wins in that time frame than we did?
NOBODY.
Not an 8-4 program.