Recruiting Football Talk VIII

#119,151
#119,151
AngryButchJones said:
Can someone give me a TLDR of wtf happened in the Gabriel Osenda thread that made KingVFL decide to take a break from here? I don't really want to try and dive through all the comments in there...seems like a hazardous waste zone lol
Click to expand...

@butchna had to get the last word in and wouldn’t leave well enough alone.
 
  • Like
Reactions: DeusExMachina, Jaxon_Vol2017, HawkVol2213 and 6 others
#119,152
#119,152
AngryButchJones said:
Can someone give me a TLDR of wtf happened in the Gabriel Osenda thread that made KingVFL decide to take a break from here? I don't really want to try and dive through all the comments in there...seems like a hazardous waste zone lol
Click to expand...
He made some statements about Elarbee that were contradicted by what the recruit in question said. There were also some apparent internal contradictions. No one attacked him. When asked about it and presented with the apparent contradictions, he alluded to taking a break.
 
  • Like
Reactions: JacketVol and SugarCC
#119,156
#119,156
Lloyd_Christmas said:
A poster took issue with King being negative about Elerbee and wouldn't let it go...was a bit too stubborn. To be fair, it doesn’t help for King to keep voicing any complaints about Elerbee knowing he's not going anywhere, so I get why butchna took issue...but it went on a bit too long.
Click to expand...
"To be fair, it doesn't help for King to keep voicing any complaints about Elerbee (Elarbee) knowing he's not going anywhere."

I find it interesting how you framed your response.......

You seem to be saying that King, and others who have critical or negative opinions/facts about the football program should just not express those opinions/facts (at least in this specific area, because, well Elarbee (Heupel's guy) isn't going anywhere. So then we should not post anything critical or negative that cuts against the status quo???

In my own experience, negative posts about the current state of TN Football (and pretty much all things related to UT sports) are met with much more criticism and ferocity than positive posts, and this board has been that way for years. When reading through the various threads, I read more positive posts than negative - but that is just my experience.

This is a board designed for engagement and discussion - I would venture to say that this "chat" board would not have grown to its current size if it was simply an echo chamber. "To each their own" I say.
 
  • Like
Reactions: Jaxon_Vol2017, InVOLuntary and BigThunder
#119,162
#119,162
patrick said:
"To be fair, it doesn't help for King to keep voicing any complaints about Elerbee (Elarbee) knowing he's not going anywhere."

I find it interesting how you framed your response.......

You seem to be saying that King, and others who have critical or negative opinions/facts about the football program should just not express those opinions/facts (at least in this specific area, because, well Elarbee (Heupel's guy) isn't going anywhere. So then we should not post anything critical or negative that cuts against the status quo???

In my own experience, negative posts about the current state of TN Football (and pretty much all things related to UT sports) are met with much more criticism and ferocity than positive posts, and this board has been that way for years. When reading through the various threads, I read more positive posts than negative - but that is just my experience.

This is a board designed for engagement and discussion - I would venture to say that this "chat" board would not have grown to its current size if it was simply an echo chamber. "To each their own" I say.
Click to expand...
Insiders carry a lot more influence than people like you and I do though. Nobody cares what we say, but insiders have at least a little ability to turn the masses against a coach or player. King, for example, has hundreds of people on this message board hanging on his every word. With that I think comes an elevated duty to be responsible with his words, which I'm sure he's well aware of and takes seriously.
 
  • Like
Reactions: JacketVol
#119,163
#119,163
Orange_Crush said:
He made some statements about Elarbee that were contradicted by what the recruit in question said. There were also some apparent internal contradictions. No one attacked him. When asked about it and presented with the apparent contradictions, he alluded to taking a break.
Click to expand...
That’s a very generous summary, considering you were the primary poster attacking King for daring to question Elerbee’s legendary recruiting prowess.

The statements (1) Elerbee is generally a weak recruiter, and (2) Elerbee connected with a specific recruit can both be objectively true. Pointing to an outlier instance to negate a general trend is a midwit take.
 
  • Like
Reactions: BigThunder and volKano
#119,164
#119,164
Vawlz said:
That’s a very generous summary, considering you were the primary poster attacking King for daring to question Elerbee’s legendary recruiting prowess.

The statements (1) Elerbee is generally a weak recruiter, and (2) Elerbee connected with a specific recruit can both be objectively true. Pointing to an outlier instance to negate a general trend is a midwit take.
Click to expand...
What is a midwit?? Just curious. Is it a term from up north or something? Never heard that. Heard nitwit but not midwit.
 
#119,167
#119,167
Vawlz said:
That’s a very generous summary, considering you were the primary poster attacking King for daring to question Elerbee’s legendary recruiting prowess.

The statements (1) Elerbee is generally a weak recruiter, and (2) Elerbee connected with a specific recruit can both be objectively true. Pointing to an outlier instance to negate a general trend is a midwit take.
Click to expand...
Attacking? Your being dramatic. And it wasn't being overly generous. You are also misrepresenting with your two points.

I told him I appreciate his recruiting info. He claimed that Elarbee gets no credit for the recruitment, yet the recruit gave him lots of credit. I asked about that. He claimed to be just sharing facts with no opinion on that. Then he admitted that he was just passing on other peoples' "sentiments", i.e. opinions.

I in no way attacked him. I was actually respectful and gave him credit/thanks for his recruiting info. The exchange is still there. Anyone can go read it.

Do you know what's NOT still there? The attacks by the angry-people after the fact. If Butch or myself had attacked him, our posts wouldn't still be there to be read. The admins would have cleaned it up with the name calling that swooped in immediately after.
 
  • Like
Reactions: SugarCC, bpalmer28 and Volator
#119,170
#119,170
What the hell is wrong with all of these people just wanting to jump on here just to start an argument or bitch about nothing that really matters. Me personally, I get on here to check up on new Vol updates and anything relative to Tennessee athletics. I have a wife!! I deal with enough!! But I swear I really think people get on here just to bitch and whine and complain for no reason whatsoever. I do not understand it to save my life. Maybe they're single. Or maybe they're just miserable individuals who want nothing more than to ruin someone's day no matter what. Believe it or not, there are people who live for this. And they won't be happy until they make you unhappy or pissed off. What a shame. And for all those people who do this crap,🖕!!!!! And go straight to 🔥🔥🔥 !!!
 
  • Like
Reactions: Dadof2Vols
#119,172
#119,172
EJVOL4LIFE said:
What the hell is wrong with all of these people just wanting to jump on here just to start an argument or bitch about nothing that really matters. Me personally, I get on here to check up on new Vol updates and anything relative to Tennessee athletics. I have a wife!! I deal with enough!! But I swear I really think people get on here just to bitch and whine and complain for no reason whatsoever. I do not understand it to save my life. Maybe they're single. Or maybe they're just miserable individuals who want nothing more than to ruin someone's day no matter what. Believe it or not, there are people who live for this. And they won't be happy until they make you unhappy or pissed off. What a shame. And for all those people who do this crap,🖕!!!!! And go straight to 🔥🔥🔥 !!!
Click to expand...
Irony is ironic. That's probably the ugliest, most negative, argumentative post I've seen since yesterday.
 
  • Like
Reactions: EJVOL4LIFE
New posts
You must log in or register to reply here.

VN Store



Back
Top