Anyone saying that Simone pulling out disqualifies her from GOAT status has no clue just how dominant she has been in her career. Undefeated in all around competitions since 2013(age 16). 7 US all around titles, 5 world all around titles, 4 or more titles at a world championship on 4 occasions, most world championship medals in history(25), most world titles in history(19).
4 skills named after her, one of which she landed while passing a kidney stone, first skill in history to award a full point instead of .9. Would have had a 5th if she had done her new vault in Olympic competition.
But she obviously can't handle pressure and now doesn't deserve to be respected as the best despite consistently doing things nobody has ever done before.