From half watching Pitt and seeing their stats, I'd say Pitt played a better game 1, mostly at one position. Not too surprising being in Y8 or whatever vs Y1.
Fwiw PFF graded them out at 88. 82 on offense and 82 on defense. We graded out at a 79. 65 on offense and 88 on defense. Biggest difference was at QB.
From my own eyes, a lot of this lines up. Thought the defenses both shut down the opponent and played elite run defense. Pickett was a lot more productive both through the air and more efficient on the ground (6.5 vs 3.1 ypc for Milton - sacks probably being quite a factor). WRs - we had 3 drops...they had 4. But they had more passes and receptions too, maybe a wash. Their WRs graded out higher, maybe had a couple nice catches (?). Both teams ran the ball very effectively.
Overall we both played trash opponents, but they definitely executed better at the most important position. We're going to have to win at both LOSs to affect that in both directions. I'm confident we can do that, but whoever is QB still has to take advantage. DL will wreak havoc, but we can't lose contain on Pickett either.
Looks like a heck of a game on paper.