BCS absolutely got it right the first year. Then it fell apart.
Wouldn’t you agree McGill?
Well...I can't argue with that...but I hated the whole "mythical" national championship crap from the time I first started watching college football.
My Dad was never a big sports guy, he is a Vol, but a veeeery casual one, thus I don't ever remember watching any CFB on Saturdays as a boy, back then before cable all you could watch was whatever the game of the week was, and it was probably never the Vols and he didn't care about any other college teams, so he didn't wathch them, but he would turn the NFL games on after church on Sunday and fall asleep..so that is why I first remember watching NFL football, and falling in love with the Steelers for some reason as a 7-8 year old..I think it was because the tough blue collar persona of those 70s Steelers teams resonated with me.
After we moved to Texas in 1980, my cousin on Dads side that already lived out there was a huge Cowboys fan and we religiously followed the NFL, but when we would visit my Moms folks in Knoxville, my Pappaw was a massive Vol fan started getting me into the Vols and learning about them, so I started casually following CFB.
So...when we moved to Knoxville in 85 just in time for the Sugar Vols, I fell in love with Tennessee and the rest is history. As the NFL was ruined for me by greed and became more purely mercenary in the late 80s and 90s I quit watching it altogether...same with pro baseball(my real first sports love) and basketball.
So...in essence, because I was first an NFL fan...I have NEVER understood the inane way it decided "champions". I have always wanted at least an eight team CFB playoff.