Ben Martin couldnt stay healthy and didnt match 5 star status. Chris Donald was an enormous bust.
We havent had luck with many 5 stars period. Below are athletes that were Rivals 5 stars. Most didnt pan out at Tennessee for one reason or another.
Kongbo
Richmond (still a year)
Phillips (still a year)
Khalil
Hurd (didnt finish)
Darick (didnt finish)
Bryce Brown (didnt finish)
Janzen Jackson (didnt finish)
Chris Donald
Ben Martin
Kenny ONeal
Brent Vinson
Demetrious Worley (didnt finish)
Brandon Jeffries (who)
James Banks (didnt finish)
Mondre Dickerson
Jonathan Mapu
Even the following didnt produce big until later in career except Kamara and Berry:
Kamara
Malone
Eric Berry
Robert Meachem
Gerald Riggs
Bryce Brown biggest hands down. #1 overall recruit by every major ranking, played hurt for one year, then left.
Honorable mention goes to David Oku, Nuke, and Chris Donald. Oh by the way, Dontavius Blair just received another black stripe. Branndon Stewart deserves a mention as well, but that turned out good for us.
Branndon Stewart only stayed one season. He gets a bust label for not beating out the most storied QB in our history?
Looks like a lat pulldown. Those are pretty useful.
Wasn't he also the QB on the team that upset a team ahead of us in '98 in the Big 12 Championship game?
The very one. Hes basing it on not producing at a school he barely played at for ONE SEASON. Youre bleeding to yell bust in that scenario. Riley Ferguson never took a snap for us and left because Dobbs took the job. Doesnt register as a bust. Devonte Blair sat on the bench for 3 seasons on a team that NEEDED an OT to contribute. Registers.
The very one. Hes basing it on not producing at a school he barely played at for ONE SEASON. Youre bleeding to yell bust in that scenario. Riley Ferguson never took a snap for us and left because Dobbs took the job. Doesnt register as a bust. Devonte Blair sat on the bench for 3 seasons on a team that NEEDED an OT to contribute. Registers.
Was he recruited to UT? Yes.
Did he do anything on campus? No.
Just because he wasnt productive here doesnt mean he was a bust in general. But for us? Undoubtedly yes.
Bust is when you have the path/opportunity to play and contribute and cant meet the challenge. Cant change the definition to just meet your narrative.