Bob Shoop came to Tennessee billed as the “Mad Scientist.” Last summer, defensive back Rashaan Gaulden called Shoop “Rain Man” and linebacker Darrin Kirkland offered that Tennessee’s defensive coordinator had “a beautiful mind.” But in hindsight, Shoop admits he out-foxed himself in 2016. Injuries ravaged a defense that was ultimately historically bad last season, as Tennessee produced its worst run unit (218.5 yards per game) in school history. In November, after allowing 73 points and 1,375 yards in wins against Kentucky and Missouri, Shoop was asked if he would “go back to his lab” to fix the unmitigated disaster that was Tennessee’s defense.
“We blew up the lab this week,” Shoop immediately joked. Only the tire-fire just kept on rolling. The very next week, the Vols allowed 608 yards and 45 points to Vanderbilt, which entered the game with the nation’s No. 116 offense. Tennessee finished the season ranked No. 95 in the country in total defense (449.2 ypg) and No. 78 in yards per play (5.84). It was a steep fall from grace for Shoop, who had presided over Top 25 units for five straight years at Vanderbilt and Penn State.
“I think at the end of the year you always critique yourself doing quality control, everything from your personnel, your scheme, your philosophy, your execution,” he said Saturday at the Big Orange Caravan in Chattanooga. “I relate to Jonathan (Kongbo). I think I might have built some unrealistic expectations, and when we got guys injured, maybe the guy calling the shots was a little bit stubborn. I think I really wanted to force a fit, that, ‘This is my style of defense.’ I probably didn't do a great job at times of tailoring things.”
“Experience is the greatest teacher,” Shoop said this spring. “The three things I look at from last year: We had a little bit of drama, a lot of injuries and we gave up too many big plays," he added Saturday. "If you watch us, we’d play eight, nine, 10 snaps in a row of really good defense and then give up a long run. An exceptionally long run, or an exceptionally long pass.”
“I still want to be aggressive, but I’m going to do a better job and we’re going to do a better job of trying to identify the strengths of the unit and develop an identity sooner than later,” he said. “I don’t think we ever really found our identity last year. Maybe not until the bowl game. The bowl game was the one game we really put together that looked like my vision for the defense.”
Against Nebraska in the Music City Bowl, Tennessee allowed just 318 yards — its fewest against a Power 5 team all year. The Cornhuskers were limited offensively without their starting quarterback, but Tennessee’s defense played with a vigor not seen for most of the year. At least anecdotally, they communicated better. They executed the scheme better, and Shoop was able to dial up some of his creative blitz packages.