volinbham
VN GURU
- Joined
- Oct 21, 2004
- Messages
- 69,737
- Likes
- 62,226
I've actually had a double eagle, and I've also bent an 8 iron (fade, not hook) about 30 yards also from a pine straw lie while playing in a pro-am at Sugar Loaf. The 8 iron shot did exactly what I wanted it to do (a rarity) and hit pin high and then spent to the right of the hole about 10 ft. The double eagle also did what I wanted it to do... it hit the green. The fact that it went in does not in any way make it a BETTER SHOT. It makes it a shot that occurs infrequently.
I can't speak for anyone else, but I certainly believe the 8 iron shot for me required more skill than hitting a 5 wood relatively straight. Would I trade the albatross for the 8 iron shot?... He11 no! But that doesn't make it a better shot or a harder shot to hit... it makes it a good golf shot with an even better break.
This is exactly the point I've been trying to make.
If we are going on rarity then Adam Scott's ace on 16 is a "better" shot than Bubba's. I don't see people making that argument.