Here are my thoughts after reviewing them..
1. Big picture, it's what I expected and what I've been saying for past 6 years.
2. There is tax planning in there for sure but tax planning is not illegal.
3. I expected to see more 1031 transactions (like kind exchanges) to defer taxation.
4. There's a good but of foreign activity, especially related to intangibles, but nothing that would give me a huge pause about conflict of interest from 17-20.
5. Trump was negatively impacted by a couple provisions of TCJA, the SALT Cap of 10K and 163j interest expense limitations.
6. Regarding SALT, it's clear he has planned around it but those laws (prepaying, taking full deduct at flow thru level). He's also AMT taxpayer (at times) so SALT cap isn't nearly as important for him as non AMT taxpayers.
7. Several of Trump's entities are subject to 163j interest limitations. Not to bore you with the details but that means a company isn't allowed an interest deduction if their operating cash flow doesn't meet a certain minimum level. Just more proof that the myth of Trump being a real estate guru is just that, a myth.
8. Trump the brand makes money. He is monetizing the brand all over the world. It's not enough to cover up #9 though.
9. Trump the real estate investor is awful. He has missed huge macro trends in the market (overly weighted in hotels, casinos, golf courses). Some of his most profitable ventures were inherited properties. Trump Tower and Mar a Lago are the exceptions to the rule here.
10. Had charitable easement in 2015 and likely and another one earlier than that. Pretty much, those tend to be fraudulent valuations. He has not monetized it however though.
11. Trump likely won't pay much in the next 5 years. He has AMT carryforwards, historical credit carryforwards, NOL carryforwards, charitable (if easement deductions are approved) carryforwards.
12. No sign of obvious tax fraud. Some questions and areas I'd probe if I was IRS.
13. Had deferral of cancellation of debt income from 2010. Smart planning there. Without that COD, he'd have overall a quarter billion of NOLs at start of 2015.
14. Considering prior disclosures and these returns, he likely went from 1995-2017 and having positive taxable income only once (2005). Contrary to what you might hear, this isn't normal for this length of time.
Conclusion - Lots of planning however the main driver of Trump's lack of taxable income isn't tax planning but consistent underperformance of his real estate portfolio. The consistent cash flow losses from his portfolio more than offset branding income and income from inherited properties. The Dems did not meet their stated objectives in this disclosure and they have created a dangerous precedent.
The Dems are missing the main point with his returns....